3
0

The problem with reasonable gun control


 invite response                
2019 Aug 7, 6:41am   5,642 views  74 comments

by BayArea   ➕follow (1)   💰tip   ignore  

There is a lie that the left and the right can agree on reasonable gun control. Although both sides say so, neither side actually believes this.

Fact: The left wants a total ban on guns. Step#1 of achieving that is getting the right to agree to reasonable gun measures. These are measure that take one small step towards a total ban on guns. With each public incident or mass shooting, the left will call for more gun control measures. This will continue in a never ending campaign.

The right will not go along with reasonable gun control measures because they know that the campaign from the left will never cease. And so the right understands that there should be no negotiation on the topic with the left.

This was explained to me recently by a friend, who owns guns, and donates to the NRA.

Take the CA gun roster, which covers which guns can be legally bought/sold in CA. Without any logic, this roster includes certain guns while excluding other guns that function in exactly the same manner. The size of this roster has changed over the years, it’s only gotten smaller.

And so the statement that both sides should be able to agree on reasonable gun reform is a lie because the left will never stop their campaign for a total gun ban. With each incident in the media, the left will continue their campaign to increase restrictions until there is only one law remaining: total ban for civilians.

Neither side will ever trust the other to be reasonable on the topic.

It’s alarming to me how many of my leftist friends and colleagues believe that only police and government should own guns. Frankly, it terrifies me that they do not see any fault with this logic as an American.

“The police will be there to protect me”

“This is the United States of America, not Cambodia. The government will never harm us”

« First        Comments 30 - 69 of 74       Last »     Search these comments

30   MisdemeanorRebel   2019 Aug 7, 12:59pm  

exfatguy says
One way to start would be to raise the minimum age to buy a semi-automatic rifle to age 24. Handguns, shotguns, and rifles can still be bought at age 18.


I like this one. Make it 25. Also voting age as well.

In fact, you have to be employed 20+ hrs a week for the past 4 years to vote, or be collecting Social Security Retirement, a Pension, etc.

Skin in the Game.
31   marcus   2019 Aug 7, 1:10pm  

Iranian_Oil_Burse says
My test is perfect in exposing this hypocricy of the left and their style of "negotiating for sensible gun laws": all take, no give.


Fail

If a majority of gun owners (not just a majority of Americans) are for sensible gun laws, then there is no "take" here by the left, and no "give" by gun owners, when you give them what they actually want.

OF course when you give both sides what they want, there is no give and take. It's just take take.

I see what you tried to do there. And I get it. The problem is you don't account for the fact that even a majority of gun owners want sensible gun safety laws - they always did.
32   GNL   2019 Aug 7, 2:07pm  

HEYYOU says
a href="/post/1326334&offset=#comment-1608368">Iranian_Oil_Burse says
The simple test the proponents of so-called "reasonable gun control" fail all the time: ask them what are they willing to offer in exchange for, say, their coveted "universal background check" or "high-capacity magazine ban" and the answer will be - "nothing". They basically practice Russian style of negotiations: all take and no give.


"exchange" - Fewer Rep/Cons' children shot in mass shootings in schools from large capacity,high speed ,hot lead throwing "arms" . Not fair? OK! Add fewer Rep/Cons being shot at concerts,shopping,theaters or just anywhere in public. OR! Rep/Cons can take their chances with shooters they don't know or see thinking that Rep/Con gun love can protect them.

My thoughts & prayers are with stupid fucking Republicans as they venture out into 400,000,000? gun America.

Well, well, well it's HeyYou with profound knowledge again. This is exactly why the right will not want to deal with you. Why are liberals so fucking stupid? Liberals fuck themselves in the ass far too often.
33   GNL   2019 Aug 7, 2:09pm  

exfatguy says
One way to start would be to raise the minimum age to buy a semi-automatic rifle to age 24. Handguns, shotguns, and rifles can still be bought at age 18.

Sure, this doesn't stop someone from stealing or borrowing a gun, but at least it gives a few year buffer to determine if someone is violently mentally ill or not. If they're prone to snap, they'd find some other way to act out before age 24, hopefully with less easy of a time.

Age has nothing to do with it. Fucking people like you should think before spewing bullshit.
34   MisdemeanorRebel   2019 Aug 7, 2:39pm  

If the majority of people were for sensible LGBTQCIA123ABC rights...

We ended up with Wax my Lady Balls, Bigot! and Funeral Parlors that have to allow Male Ushers to wear dresses and lipstick.
35   MisdemeanorRebel   2019 Aug 7, 2:41pm  

If the majority of people were for sensible LGBTQCIA123ABC rights...

We ended up with Wax my Lady Balls, Bigot! and Funeral Parlors that have to allow Male Ushers to wear dresses and lipstick.

How about sensible Immigration Reform (total amnesty, minimal enforcement) or sensible cultural accomodation (pray to Mecca, kids -- and America was established by EVIL! WHITE! DEAD! MALES!)
36   Patrick   2019 Aug 7, 6:50pm  

OccasionalCortex says
Patrick, the 'ignore' feature is not working again as I am now starting to see his posts even tho I have marcus set on 'ignore'.



@OccasionalCortex if you go to https://patrick.net/edit_profile and look at the bottom under "ignored users" do you see marcus listed?
37   GNL   2019 Aug 7, 8:23pm  

marcus says
HonkpilledMaster says
At Civil Partnership.


Actually I sort of agree, but I don't have a problem with marriage. But if your slippery slope argument makes sense, you should be saying that only by keeping homosexuality illegal could we prevent a majority eventually in favor of child drag gueens.

You're being obtuse.
38   GNL   2019 Aug 7, 8:30pm  

HonkpilledMaster says
I'll accept Red Flag Federal Gun Laws in return for both Bourse's Federal CCW (that States are powerless to stop) AND

A filing by the Democratic Party stating they won't introduce Gun Laws in Congress for the next 25 years OF ANY KIND, and issues a $5 Billion Dollar + 5% Annual Interest Bond against non-compliance guaranteed by the DNC, DLC, and each and every State Democratic Organization individually and collectively.

The money to be paid directly to the Republican Party and NRA if any Democrat introduces a Gun Control Bill in either house.

I think this is giving up too much. Unless, that is, the red flag law is tight. Meaning in no way ambiguous. A neighbor can't simply get mad and call the cops to raid your home. A Dr. or at least 3 different people of sound mind and over, at least, 18 years of age.
39   Patrick   2019 Aug 8, 6:31pm  

OK, that seems to be a real bug. I'll try to figure it out.
40   marcus   2019 Aug 8, 6:51pm  

I don't see her
41   MisdemeanorRebel   2019 Aug 8, 7:16pm  

WineHorror1 says
I think this is giving up too much. Unless, that is, the red flag law is tight. Meaning in no way ambiguous. A neighbor can't simply get mad and call the cops to raid your home. A Dr. or at least 3 different people of sound mind and over, at least, 18 years of age.


My fear is that libbies will simply tell "Family" Lawyers and Judges to issue them "liberally" in divorce cases, even in no-faults.

BTW, you shouldn't be able to file no faults with a restraining order, you should be legally required to file a with-fault divorce. Get rid of that trick.
42   richwicks   2019 Aug 8, 7:28pm  

I never can read past something like:

"Fact: The left wants a total ban on guns."

Look, the left may be wrong on gun control, but telling "the left" what THEY (supposedly) want, it's just utter stupidity. It only serves to produce an argument and gets everybody to dig in their heels and stop thinking.

What you need to do with somebody that is in favor of more gun control is simply point out to the person that what they are doing is advocating that the only people that should be armed are people who lied the nation into the Iraq War, blew up Libya, and repeatedly, and falsely, claimed Assad was gassing his own people.

Now, if you want those megalomaniac nuts to be the only group that is armed, you should do some more thinking. We have an entirely criminal government and have had that for more than 2 decades.

And incidentally, if you're on "the right", and object to me pointing out that the Bush adminstration lied us into a war, you ought to consider the possibility that leadership of "the left" and "the right" are entirely corrupt, because they are.
46   steverbeaver   2019 Aug 9, 12:09am  

Well, have you been to a Walmart during normal working hours, esp on EBT day? My experience has been squatemalens buying junk food with gibs… results may differ vs your gated enclave.
47   HeadSet   2019 Aug 9, 6:32am  

marcus says


Let's have a ban on fully automatic weapons that can shoot 600 rounds per minute. Oh, wait, we already do.
48   BayArea   2019 Aug 9, 6:50am  

Fully automatic firearms are illegal
Murdering people is illegal

Some people don’t follow laws, and never will. Should there be more laws that take away the freedom of law abiding citizens?

Left can’t meme
49   RC2006   2019 Aug 9, 7:29am  

HeadSet says
marcus says


Let's have a ban on fully automatic weapons that can shoot 600 rounds per minute. Oh, wait, we already do.


Left can't meme.
53   GNL   2019 Aug 16, 6:28am  

Booger says

You post great memes but I'm not sure what this one means.
54   HeadSet   2019 Aug 16, 6:31am  

You post great memes but I'm not sure what this one means.

Man proposes, lady behind sees it, man with other lady nervous that his lady wants the same thing. China does not want Hong Kong envying the right to bear arms.
55   GNL   2019 Aug 16, 7:07am  

HeadSet says
You post great memes but I'm not sure what this one means.

Man proposes, lady behind sees it, man with other lady nervous that his lady wants the same thing. China does not want Hong Kong envying the right to bear arms.

Thank you. I haven't been following the Hong Kong events.
57   Patrick   2019 Aug 18, 5:50pm  

Patrick says
OK, that seems to be a real bug. I'll try to figure it out.


@OccasionalCortex this is the problem:

There are two ways that comments can appear on a page on patrick.net:

1. comments are loaded when the whole page is loaded
2. comments are loaded without a page reload (it just pops up) when one user submits a new comment and another user is on that same url

The "instant comment" loading (the second way) does not check the ignores table. If you see a comment by marcus which disappears when you reload the page, then the comment definitely appeared the second way.

It would be kind of hard to fix, but I'll try to think of ways that won't hurt performance much.
58   BayArea   2019 Sep 17, 8:17pm  

WineHorror1 says


No more compromising
59   Onvacation   2019 Sep 18, 5:42am  

marcus says
holding hate rallies against gays

When did that ever happen?
60   FortWayneAsNancyPelosiHaircut   2019 Sep 18, 10:20am  

Onvacation says
marcus says
holding hate rallies against gays

When did that ever happen?


There are hate rallies against straight white people, those are the norm in California. Haven't seen a single one the other way, it would be on CNN 24/7 otherwise.
61   RWSGFY   2019 Sep 18, 10:41am  

WineHorror1 says


But anyone can still buy a machine gun on the interwebz and have it delivered to their door by UPS no question asked!
62   MisdemeanorRebel   2019 Sep 21, 1:34am  

oakland says
Do you really want to live in a world where everyone is a mindless sheep, everyone has the same thinking, and everyone wears the same clothes?


Nah, let's live in Kashmir or Yugoslavia so we can C'mon Feel the Diversity.
63   Reality   2019 Sep 21, 6:44am  

Considering the tendency of gun-free zones drawing mass-shooters, the recurrence of mass-stabbers and (attempted) mass-murders using cars plowing into crowds, along with the usual multiple minutes that it takes police to arrive when seconds matter . . . . the only reasonable gun-control policy is: mandatory gun ownership and carry! If the last digit of your SSN matches the last digit of the calendar date, it is your responsibility to carry your gun when out in public! Exempting only the very young, very old and the infirm.

If you want to vote, you have to pass either a shooting range qualification (such as putting at least 50% bullets inside the outermost ring on a target at 25ft with a hand gun, 25yds with a rifle) or pay at least $1000 annual income tax or being at least 75yo. No free-loaders begging for more enslavement.
64   Rin   2019 Sep 21, 7:02am  

Repeat ...

http://patrick.net/post/1326406/2019-08-09-since-a-vast-majority-of-criminals-get-guns-from-the-underworld

Since a vast majority of criminals get guns from the underworld ... then they're illegally owned and thus, throw 'em in jail, just for that. Is that something that the police along with the DA offices can't pull off?

Do that, again and again, and very soon, you'll see the gun laws work for law abiding citizens.

The problem is enforcement of existing laws.
65   rocketjoe79   2019 Sep 21, 7:21am  



But anyone can still buy a machine gun on the interwebz and have it delivered to their door by UPS no question asked!

Not True - any gun transfer must proceed through someone with a Federal Firearms License. You generally pay a small fee for the privilege, and the sale is recorded for the Feds.
66   RWSGFY   2019 Sep 21, 7:26am  

rocketjoe79 says


But anyone can still buy a machine gun on the interwebz and have it delivered to their door by UPS no question asked!

Not True - any gun transfer must proceed through someone with a Federal Firearms License. You generally pay a small fee for the privilege, and the sale is recorded for the Feds.


Really? No way!
67   Bd6r   2019 Sep 21, 9:42pm  

@Patrick,
oakland (#72) is a bot as well. They seem to have nearly identical programming.
68   Patrick   2019 Sep 21, 9:45pm  

Yes, deleted now thanks @6rdB

« First        Comments 30 - 69 of 74       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions