2
0

Petrodollar Nonsense Explained


 invite response                
2022 Mar 21, 2:20pm   4,465 views  50 comments

by null   ➕follow (4)   💰tip   ignore  

I copied the original tweets here for those who don't want to go to Twitter (https://twitter.com/coloradotravis/status/1504981560537231362)

Tiny brains throwing around ‘petrodollar’ like it’s a thing are my favorite.

It’s not the ‘petrodollar’ it’s the ‘everything dollar.’

You see, only a tiny fraction (10%) of America’s GDP relies on exporting stuff.

Compare that to the EU at 45%
1/


The US has the largest GDP in the world but it’s also the most self-reliant — and therefore resilient — GDP in the world.

And because of that, everyone wants access to the American consumer: it’s the most resilient source of aggregate demand.
2/

That’s why when we have economic or financial crises, everyone else gets dragged down.

And it’s why other countries’ economic crises don’t necessarily drag us down: because trade with them is a garnish on an 32oz dry-aged economic porterhouse that’s all ours.
3/

There is some fever dream hallucination that the value of the dollar relies on energy trade.

Horse puckey.

The value of the dollar is that accepting it as payment gets you access to the best market on the planet.

Because that’s how America pays for stuff.
4/

Now: if you, as a sovereign nation, don’t want access to that demand then uh… I guess that’s fine.

Have fun enjoying drastically reduced economic potential.
/5

Consider this: in a world where all global trade were to simply cease, everyone’s quality of life would go down.

But on an relative basis, America would be even more ahead economically.

Comments 1 - 40 of 50       Last »     Search these comments

1   richwicks   2022 Mar 21, 2:28pm  

The dollar's value is entirely contingent up people's willingness to accept it as worthwhile commodity.

If China, Russia, and India continued to trade in the dollar, but then immediately converted it to a commodity asset, it would destroy the dollar in short order.

Hyperinflation is an political event, not an economic one.
2   richwicks   2022 Mar 21, 2:38pm  

HunterTits says
No countries that rely on a lot of exports relative to their GDP wants demand for their own currency to drive up the value of their own currency. Then they couldn't export as much.


Why would they want to export so much?

Why exactly are they eager to trade goods and products from some toilet paper that the Federal Reserve can make in unlimited quantities for nothing?

People keep crowing about GDP. GDP is just a measure of how much churn there is an economy. It isn't a measure of the health of a nation.
3   FortWayneAsNancyPelosiHaircut   2022 Mar 21, 4:01pm  

So in a short version, how fucked are we right now with whatever inflation or other countries using their currency to trade? What does that mean for us?

Are they simply resetting entire world economy down right now?
4   richwicks   2022 Mar 21, 5:25pm  

HunterTits says
richwicks says
Why would they want to export so much?


Uh, is that a serious question?


It's an entirely serious question.

They are trading work and labor for something that can, and is, created at will for no effort and no work.

You might do work for me if I produce trinkets that you can reasonably trade for good and services, but it's just a scam - you're trading the worthless trinkets with people who don't know they are worthless trinkets.

Dollar bills today are kind of like glass beads were 200 years ago. It's just surprising to me how gullible people are.
5   Patrick   2022 Mar 23, 3:39am  

HunterTits says
The US has the largest GDP in the world but it’s also the most self-reliant — and therefore resilient — GDP in the world.


What about our imports from China?
6   rocketjoe79   2022 Mar 23, 9:35am  

Patrick says
HunterTits says
The US has the largest GDP in the world but it’s also the most self-reliant — and therefore resilient — GDP in the world.


What about our imports from China?


Dollars thru china just come back around again, right?
7   FortWayneAsNancyPelosiHaircut   2022 Mar 23, 9:55am  

HT if you don't mind, can you explain how will this affect us here in US? Are there any financial recommendations that are good to make? I don't completely understand this petrodollar thing, and most importantly I don't understand what it means for us.
8   stereotomy   2022 Mar 23, 10:36am  

The petrodollar is one of the pillars of dollar support. All payment for oil must be settled in dollars, thanks to Nixon's negotiations with the swing OPEC member Saudi Arabia after he abrogated the convertibility of dollars to gold in 1972. The US supplies SA with as much weapons as it wants to buy and takes care of enemies of SA (like Iran, Iraq, Libya, Syria, etc.).

Another pillar is the SWIFT system for setting international payments, which is also controlled by the US. If the US doesn't like you because you don't play along, you're banned from SWIFT (like Russia right now).

The third pillar is the US military, which enforces US hegemony, as well as (largely) guaranteeing freedom of the seas and world trade.
9   AmericanKulak   2022 Mar 23, 12:19pm  

richwicks says
Hyperinflation is an political event, not an economic one.



This. Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon - Friedman.
11   richwicks   2022 Mar 23, 10:17pm  

Patrick says






FINALLY - Russia is supporting the ruble.

When will China ask for Renminbi / Yuan for their stuff?

Maybe other countries will stop racing to the bottom, and just let the US and Europe win that race on their own.
13   HeadSet   2023 Feb 8, 9:05pm  

cisTits says

Patrick says
What about our imports from China?


~4% of our GDP.

Imports are about 10% of GDP. Half that is with the NAFTA nations.

Imports by definition are not part of GDP. The "D" in GDP stands for domestic.
14   Patrick   2023 Feb 9, 12:00am  

I think the ultimate value of the US dollar is that Saudi Arabia demands dollars for their oil.

That's what I think of as the "petrodollar".
15   richwicks   2023 Feb 9, 1:46am  

cisTits says


Patrick says







All the petrodollar is is any US money banked overseas and used overseas for transactions that occur via bookkeeping methods. Not limited to.mideast or oil money anymore. In fact, the majority isn't.



It's just a continuing scam at this point in my opinion. I don't know why China and India still participate in it. Russia quit it which is probably the true conflict the US has with Russia, and we are showing ourselves to be a paper tiger. Time will tell. I think Russia is legitimately afraid of us, but at the same time, I can see how weak our military really is. Sure, we can kick the shit out of a 3rd world country (sometimes..), Russia is not a 3rd world nation.
16   🎂 Tenpoundbass   2023 Feb 9, 6:54am  

Or as I like to describe the US Dollar, it's still the best game in town, irregardless what happens to the price of Oil, or what other Countries gripe about.
My unwanted useless Petro Dollar repository is still open, I opened it in 2007 but nobody on Patnet has never sent me their junk dollars.
17   richwicks   2023 Feb 9, 5:12pm  

Tenpoundbass says

My unwanted useless Petro Dollar repository is still open, I opened it in 2007 but nobody on Patnet has never sent me their junk dollars.


I'll trade it for gold, after all, isn't the dollar the best game in town? Give me your worthless metal for my worthless dollars.
18   RWSGFY   2023 Mar 26, 7:25am  

cisTits says

richwicks says
Why would they want to export so much?


Uh, is that a serious question?


For him - yes. =))
19   🎂 Tenpoundbass   2023 Mar 26, 7:33am  

richwicks says


Tenpoundbass says

My unwanted useless Petro Dollar repository is still open, I opened it in 2007 but nobody on Patnet has never sent me their junk dollars.

I'll trade it for gold, after all, isn't the dollar the best game in town? Give me your worthless metal for my worthless dollars.


Wait! Are you trading Ass for your Gold? How are you getting the gold you get?
20   Bd6r   2023 Mar 26, 7:59am  

I have been hearing about petrodollar demise and dollar collapse for last 15 years. ZH is full of articles such as “Zimbabwe bought oil from Sudan and paid in Mongolian tugriks which signals end of dollar hegemony”. I am still waiting for that.

BTW logical arguments will not work on the petrodollar religion adherents more than scientific arguments worked on mask religion adherents
21   komputodo   2023 Mar 26, 8:49am  

Tenpoundbass says

Or as I like to describe the US Dollar, it's still the best game in town,

And the sad part of that is that even after devaluating about 95%, its still the best FIAT in play.
22   RWSGFY   2023 Mar 26, 9:11am  

komputodo says


Tenpoundbass says


Or as I like to describe the US Dollar, it's still the best game in town,

And the sad part of that is that even after devaluating about 95%, its still the best FIAT in play.



.... and no non-fiat plays exist. Guaddafi was our last hope until Bernanke ordered him killed...
23   🎂 Tenpoundbass   2023 Mar 26, 10:21am  

Economic Lemmings: "Fiat money is no good buy Bit Coins and Gold!"
Also Economic Lemmings: "I lost half of my money on Bit Coin! So I bought more Gold when it went over $1600 an oz. "

I'm still waiting on the "For Sale" sign that says "2 oz. of Gold" as the price. .
24   AD   2023 Mar 26, 10:43am  

cisTits says

Consider this: in a world where all global trade were to simply cease, everyone’s quality of life would go down.

But on an relative basis, America would be even more ahead economically.


That is true, as you stated we do not have an export driven economy.

We are somewhat self sufficient as far as agriculture, healthcare, energy, higher education, and technology development.

However we do rely on some imports for our supply chain as look at how many products from China, Taiwan, etc are needed for manufacturing in the USA such as automobiles.

For example, how many parts from China go into Whirlpool's refrigerators that are manufactured / assembled in the USA ?

Look at how Japan was cut off before start of World War 2 in regards to oil, which it had to extensively import.

.
25   Ceffer   2023 Mar 26, 10:56am  

We only rely on China because the geniuses purposely exported our industrial capacity to them.
26   richwicks   2023 Mar 26, 11:07am  

cisTits says

richwicks says
Why would they want to export so much?


Uh, is that a serious question?


@cisTits?

Yes, it is. Why haven't you answered it?

What, precisely, does Russia need from anybody else? None of you chuckleheads can answer that. There's this BULLSHIT from the retards in our government that thinks "money" is something Russia needs. For what?

RWSGFY says

For him - yes. =))


@RWSGFY - answer the question.

You're one of the dumbest, snidest people I've ever run across on the Internet, and I've been on it before web browsers were invented.

Instead of appling derision, which is nothing more than a stupid ad-hominem attack, explain just what Russia needs "money" for? What are they, the Russians, using money to trade for?

Can you guys answer this? Show you have the capacity to be less stupid and fucking retarded than our own fucking dumb shit totally moronic Neocons. They are either the stupidest mother fuckers to EVER gain power in the United States, or they are a 5th column in the United States whose purpose is to destroy this country. Show that you are smarter than they are.

What precisely does Russia need from anybody else?
27   richwicks   2023 Mar 26, 11:13am  

cisTits says

richwicks says
It's an entirely serious question.


No. It isn't.

Just an expression of ignorance.

Here it is in a simple, "See Spot Run" format. Exporting Nations for Dummies, basically:

https://youtu.be/l0CQsifJrMc?t=199


Noo, @cisTits - answer the question. Don't point to a fucking haystack and say the needle is in there.

What does Russia need US or European currency for? To trade for what?

You are acting as if this has an stupefyingly easy answer, yet you can't answer it. All of you people are like "PFFT! You don't KNOW that answer?!? HARDE HAR HAR!!! You dumb!"

I do know the answer, I'm demonstrating to other people you don't. Russia doesn't need ANYTHING from the United States or Europe, Nothing at all. There's some luxury goods they don't mind having, but they need NOTHING from the US or Europe.

Europe on the other hand DOES need VITAL resources from Russia - energy. This is not a luxury for them, this is absolutely necessary to keep functioning.
28   RayAmerica   2023 Mar 26, 11:22am  

US Bank Trouble Heralds The End Of Dollar Reserve System

Bank crisis not a credit quality problem but stems instead from now-impossible task of financing America’s ever-expanding foreign debt...

Read it here:
https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/us-bank-trouble-heralds-end-dollar-reserve-system
29   AD   2023 Mar 26, 11:23am  

richwicks says

What precisely does Russia need from anybody else?


True, as Russia could probably sustain itself depending on the demands of its average standard of living.

Does it need to import vital medical supplies like antibiotics ?

How much of its public transportation's operation and maintenance are dependent on foreign goods and services (i.e., technical representatives from other countries assist with complex repairs, parts from China to replace worn brake parts, etc.).

A standard of living that is more complex increases likelihood for more imports in a global economy.
.
30   richwicks   2023 Mar 26, 11:51am  

ad says

Does it need to import vital medical supplies like antibiotics ?


Possibly, but India produces this. Given our fucking pharmaceutical system, they would probably be healthier without buying any of our poisons.

ad says

How much of its public transportation's operation and maintenance are dependent on foreign goods and services (i.e., technical representatives from other countries assist with complex repairs, parts from China to replace worn brake parts, etc.).


All that, will be replaced. Russia has been trying to do trade of goods and services with Europe for 30 years, the US keeps interfering with them, finally Russia is at the "fuck you moment". They will no longer pursue any trade with Europe or the United States. Their manufacturing is shit, I know that, I think that's finally about to change. Reliance on ANYTHING from Europe or the US is bad for them, they have 5 years to get their asses straight on manufacturing or so before they run out of parts, but they are doing well with China and they export significant amounts of energy to China.

ad says

A standard of living that is more complex increases likelihood for more imports in a global economy.


I don't see why. Has trade with China increased the standard of living in the United States? We've been doing it for 30 years. Has this helped the United States?

If Russia (and it's a big IF) can get rid of their systemic corruption and incentivize creation and and business development within their own country, they will have a good future ahead. The West is just too fucking corrupt to bother with.
31   AD   2023 Mar 26, 12:06pm  

richwicks says

I don't see why. Has trade with China increased the standard of living in the United States? We've been doing it for 30 years. Has this helped the United States?


First thought is cheap computers like the $200 Chromebook (Acer, 15 inch screen) I am using now. Cheap computers can be a powerful tool that offers many productivity advantages. Look also at how valuable free services like Google Drive and Open Office.

Cheap cameras like from Wyze can be used to keep an eye on elderly and young children in a home. Look at medical pendants or necklaces that can be worn and can detect a fall.

I can see there are a lot of western robber barons like Soros who get protection by wrapping themselves with the globalist and Woke flags. I think there is still an active arrest warrant in Thailand for Soros.

My degrees are mechanical engineering and industrial engineering (IE). I use an IE mindset to look at how to merge free or cheap, readily available (commercial off the shelf) products to make life easier.

But I can see Russia easily being able to sustain itself by just relying on India, China and Africa. Russia is an innovative country with hardy people; they can figure things out a lot on their own. I would say some of the USA is like that, especially Rednecks (i.e. my people) and homesteaders in Idaho, Montana, Alaska, etc.

.
32   richwicks   2023 Mar 26, 12:24pm  

ad says

First thought is cheap computers like the $200 Chromebook (Acer, 15 inch screen) I am using now. Cheap computers can be a powerful tool that offers many productivity advantages. Look also at how valuable free services like Google Drive and Open Office.


That's from China. Not from the West. Russia has (officially) moved to Linux as well. People dumb enough to continue to use Windows, do it to their own detriment.

All the stuff you listed aren't anywhere close to strictly necessary either.

Europe needs energy, period. They need energy to LIVE.

Russia at this point, after being stabbed in the back, over and over and over again, should just be like "fuck you Europe". Let them freeze, let their factories close, fuck them. They have been patient and generous for a LONG time. Fuck Europe. Russia doesn't need Europe, Europe needs Russia, and Russia should just let Europe fucking fail.

The Neocunts want another fucking Cold War? Fine, do it. Russia will win this time. Can't you see the West's weakness? We need to have constant propaganda, and constant censorship, in order to even stay afloat at this point. WE are the USSR this time around. I don't see why people don't understand this.

Can't you see how much stupid propaganda is needed to keep this all going? "Russia blew up the Nordstream pipeline" - I remember when we used to make FUN of the USSR for propaganda as stupid as that and pointing out what a bunch of losers they were because they needed censorship to keep the government in power.

For 20 years, all I have seen in the US is failure after failure after failure after failure, as MORONS that keep making "mistakes" keep falling up. The people in power in this nation are destroying this nation, and people just continue to ignore it. People have been warning about this for 2 decades, and nobody will listen, nobody will do anything to stop it, they just go along to get along, so fine, fuck it. If you all want to allow a dictatorship tyranny to take root in the US, go ahead.
33   AD   2023 Mar 26, 1:00pm  

richwicks says

The people in power in this nation are destroying this nation, and people just continue to ignore it.


As long as they have a basic standard of living (a roof over head, cheap food in kitchen, medicaid, large screen LCD with Pluto TV, Tubi, etc.) with help from the government, then they won't complain. That is what is being leveraged as far as government having control over the masses.

Also the government uses Woke and virtue signaling as the proverbial thumb over the masses especially keeping anyone of the masses from rebelling or being dissidents.

.
34   🎂 Tenpoundbass   2023 Mar 26, 1:04pm  

ad says

My degrees are mechanical engineering and industrial engineering (IE). I use an IE mindset to look at how to merge free or cheap, readily available (commercial off the shelf) products to make life easier.


It's been my experience that companies that abandon their proprietary IP process, to shoe horn it into readily available free or cheap open source options. They end up with a whole suite of non-utilized or over utilized options that doesn't really service their core needs, and does very little to distinguish them from their competitors.
They then end up having to keep a separate set of records that does the brainwork and calculations for their business model, to which they then have to plug the sums and totals of in their readily cheap available options.

It's a crime what people are doing to companies, driving them into the ground to make their resume make them seem like they are the new thing migration king.
35   richwicks   2023 Mar 26, 1:12pm  

cisTits says

richwicks says


Why would they want to export so much?


Learn economics.


<sarcasm>What a surprise, you can't explain it. What a shock!</sarcasm>

I get sick of people being full of shit, stop being full of shit. Delusion is one of the worst problems that I have to deal with. If people could actually THINK, see things as they ACTUALLY are, we'd be in a much better world. But, apparently, some people just want to be fucking full of shit, because it's dangerous to call out the fucking incompetence and backward policies that fucks over our entire nation.

Russia isn't the real focus of this proxy war in my opinion, it's us, the US population, and the European population. We can spend 100 billion dollars on bullshit in Ukraine, but we can't spend a fucking dime on Palestine Ohio. Our government doesn't give a FUCK about the population of the United States, and neither do you.
36   richwicks   2023 Mar 26, 1:16pm  

cisTits says


richwicks says


Noo, cisTits - answer the question. Don't point to a fucking haystack and say the needle is in there.

What does Russia need US or European currency for? To trade for what?


Now you are goal post moving.



No - I keep fucking asking you, what does Russia need "money" for? They don't need to trade at ALL with Europe or the United States. In fact, they should stop entirely.

It's Europe that needs Russia, and it's the United States that is the predator on top of Europe and the Middle East. Russia doesn't need any fucking money from either the fuckers of the EU or the fuckers of the United States.

Answer the fucking question. Don't be "duh, learn economics" - you fucking explain it. I understand geopolitics and economics to some extent, the stupid Neocunts don't or they are purpose sabotaging THIS nation and Europe. Who is inviting in all these refugees into Europe? That's destroying the continent, is Russia doing that? Who is inviting in all these illegal immigrants to the United States? Russian doing that?

You mother fuckers are SO EASILY FOOLED, and impossible to teach, that we're stuck with domestic traitors fucking you and ME over. People like me, try to talk to IDIOTS like you, you won't listen, and you outnumber of 10 to 1. Thanks for being a willing dupe.
37   Eric Holder   2023 Mar 27, 1:07pm  

cisTits says

richwicks says



Don't be "duh, learn economics" - you fucking explain it.


Already did. But Not my prob you're messed up in understanding it.


Pretending he doesn't understand even the simplest of concepts if they go against the line he's toeing is his usual shtick, lol.
38   Bd6r   2023 Mar 27, 7:51pm  

If he is trolling I really admire his skills, it is level 9000+. If not, then…
39   richwicks   2023 Mar 27, 8:49pm  

Eric Holder says


cisTits says


richwicks says


Don't be "duh, learn economics" - you fucking explain it.


Already did. But Not my prob you're messed up in understanding it.



Pretending he doesn't understand even the simplest of concepts if they go against the line he's toeing is his usual shtick, lol.



Give me a break. Currency is used for trade of goods and service. EU notes are used to trade for good and services from Europe. What goods and services does Russia need from Europe? Not WANT, NEED.

No answer.

What goods and services does Russia need from the United States? Not WANT, NEED.

@"Eric Holder", @cisTits, @Bd6r - you're all full of shit. This is why you resort to ad - hominem attack when people point out "you are full of shit, and I'm calling you out on being full of shit".

Russia doesn't NEED anything from Europe or the United States. I bet they have some dependency on China, not certain they have any real dependency on India, but they are neighbors.

This pathological insanity of Americans thinking the rest of the world depends on them. Depends on the United States for WHAT? You guys have no fucking clue. It's not technology either. Do you know China has their own internal chipset for their last supercomputer?

https://en.wikipedia.org//wiki/Supercomputing_in_China

And it's not using an American chipset. We don't really (anymore) know who has the FASTEST computer, that may be inaccurate, but China doesn't use our chips at all now. What (we think) they are using is the Sunway SW26010 - they do NOT export these.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunway_SW26010

We don't know the instruction set, they developed their own compilers and their own optimizer for them. Meanwhile, the US has finally fucking realize maybe we shouldn't be exporting all of our technology to China. Finally.

Of course because STEM has been infected with this wokeness bullshit, we are highly dependent on foreign workers at this point. Graduate from Stanford or Harvard? Well, only hire them if they are Asian, or white - all other races are getting social promotion. Flipping a coin with that.

You know what the FINAL bitch of this is? Because it's BLATANTLY obvious that intelligence agencies have infiltrated US high tech, nobody wants US high tech now. Buying a router? It's infiltrated, I guarantee it. Backdoors are built into x86 processors, ALL of them. China might very well be doing the same thing, but if people haven't found it, they can't exploit it. What the NSA can do with these backdoors, any hacker can do, even if they are Russian or Chinese.

You guys simply have no clue. Our intelligence agencies have FUCKED US hard.
40   richwicks   2023 Mar 27, 9:14pm  

cisTits says


richwicks says


What, precisely, does Russia need from anybody else?


No. I won't. Because it has nothing to do with what I was talking about.



Russia doesn't need EU currency or US currency. That's the "money" that stupid assholes like Condoleezza Rice are talking about.


original link

I cannot believe how fucking stupid these people are and/or how naive they are - but to see people blindly repeat this stuff without even fucking thinking about it blows my mind.

Russia doesn't need ANYTHING from the US or EU, and that includes "money" from the US or EU because the ONLY function of "money" from the US or EU is to trade for EU and US goods and services, which they don't need.

Condi Rice is one of the stupidest people EVER to be in our government, and I know Kamala Harris is there now. You're listening to her. You're repeating HER bullshit.

You don't even understand what "money" represents. If Russia isn't going to trade with the US or Europe (which they can't, and haven't in any meaningful way for over a decade), what is Russia supposed to do with what what Condi Rice describes as "money" anyhow?

Only the incompetent and the corrupt rise to the top of the US at this point. That's why we're fucked and you clapping seals can't see it, because you think "well, Condi Rice wouldn't be in that position if she didn't know what she was talking about", even though she clearly doesn't know what she's talking about, and neither do you. Use your brain, don't just repeat stupid propaganda.

Hey, want some Confederate money? How about some Lincoln greenbacks! I mean, you wouldn't want to run out of them!! Right? Condi?

Comments 1 - 40 of 50       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions