patrick.net

Malcolm says

That is almost word for word for the basis of the final solution.

Except, the Jews in Germany weren't migrants, integrated well, spoke the language, paid taxes, were less likely to be in the poor house, and were totally uninterested in converting Germany to Judaism. Almost all Jews were utterly Westernized.

Did 1920s-1930s Germany have problems with packs of Jews robbing stores, pickpocketing people on the tram, and gangs of young Jewish medical school students raping women?

Who does that in modern Europe? Jewish Guys at the Max Planck Institute in Germany, or Arab Gangs in Malmo and Paris?

If this was said about any single group in the USA, that would be considered racist.

Sorry, but you can’t hold people accountable for other pepple’s crimes just because they are of the same race.

Either individuals are judged by their individual actions, or there are differences in races pertaining to honesty, intelligence...etc.

I’m fine with either one. I just wish that there was some social consistency.

Malcolm says

In other news, Buddhists are killing Muslims in Myanmar. Buddhists are known for putting pacifism above their own lives, the conclusion; you have to be a special kind of shit hole race for Buddhists to want to exterminate you.

Yeah and what's worse the propaganda mainstream globalist/leftist/cultural-marxist media, esp. in Europe is doing the bidding of the globalist EUrocrats and reports that the Buddhists are hostile and persecute the Muslims! The Buddhists are the latest Nazis! I don't know how these assholes writing these shill stories can sleep at night. Luckily many people have woken up and don't believe a thing anymore the US and European mainstream media reports. Just feel bad for the Buddhists, wtf has mainstream journalism come to.

Culture produces thought patters in those who hold to that culture, not all cultures are equal.

The problem with race is that is obsfucates Culture with physical characteristics. The PoMos deliberately confound the two in an attempt to weaken Western Civilization by trying to create an apparent paradox with Western Principles that doesn't actually exist.

This is why you constantly have to remind people accusing you of being a racist for your Islamophobia that "Islam isn't a race." (and phobia is an unreasonable fear), when they call you racist for hating Islam. Notice you never have to say "Buddhism/Catholicism isn't a race".

That's why one group of Migrants with Middle Eastern Blood has a problem with Laws, Crime, and Fanatical Terrorism, and other where the DNA difference is almost undetectable from the other group, does not (and does not care about spreading it's religion one bit), indeed it loads up it's host civilization with science (and to be fair a bit of idealistic perfectionist whining). It's Cultural, not Racial.

I'm openly a Western Civilization Chauvenist.

TwoScoopsPlissken says

Almost all Jews were utterly Westernized

We wouldn't have hugely successful businesses or an entertainment industry if it wasn't for the Jews. Jews made the entertainment industry in the 1920's: Ben Bernie, Al Jolson, Eddie Cantor, the Warner brothers, Abe Lyman, Julie Wentz, Gus Kahn, Roger Wolfe Kahn, Sigmund Romberg, George and Ira Gershwin and on and on.

NDrLoR says

We wouldn't have hugely successful businesses or an entertainment industry if it wasn't for the Jews. Jews made the entertainment industry in the 1920's: Ben Bernie, Al Jolson, Eddie Cantor, the Warner brothers, Abe Lyman, Julie Wentz, Gus Kahn, Roger Wolfe Kahn, Sigmund Romberg, George and Ira Gershwin and on and on.

Those Jews and their immediate Jewish successors in the 30s-70s embraced the Hollywood Code and blacklisted Communists for most of that time and made everything from "It's A Wonderful Life" to "Green Beret" to "Godfather" possible.

Let's recall as late as the late 2000s a single lesbian kiss was enough to have Hollywood's Motion Picture Rating system give a movie an "NR", the kiss of death effectively keeping it out of most commercial theaters; only art theaters would screen just a movie.

What changed until Obama I and II? LGBTQ lobbying and for the first time, CHYna being involved in movie financing and getting editorial control. ONLY then did Hollywood change.

Good time to revisit this thread, so bumpity bump.

"The issue is never the issue. The issue is always the Revolution" - I forgot.

MisdemeanorRebel says

Did 1920s-1930s Germany have problems with packs of Jews robbing stores, pickpocketing people on the tram, and gangs of young Jewish medical school students raping women?

They did have the largest LGBT+ movement, Berlin was the San Francisco of Europe or world until most Germans had enough of it.

DemocratsAreTotallyFucked says

Someone who was actually concerned about the disadvantaged would organize and encourage volunteers to read to those underprivileged kids.

I experienced white privilege once. They let me review my mugshots and I got to pick the most flattering one.

Patrick says

Putin himself addressing a room full of rabbis said that 85 percent of the bolsheviks were Jewish.

Patrick says

Needs the year and source to verify.

I'm pretty sure it's true.

https://www.unz.com/pub/jhr__the-jewish-role-in-the-bolshevik-revolution-and-russias-early-soviet-regime/

The "Military Revolutionary Committee", CRT's favorite time frame, lasted less than 5 months: Late October 1917 – March 1918, with persons rotating in and out and no more than 6 Jews and 28 persons at any time. Like /pol images overlap current and former executives to maximize proof, so do various publications. The Unz article linked quotes some publications written in Berlin in 1934 if you catch my drift

https://www.ssoar.info/ssoar/bitstream/handle/document/37283/ssoar-hsr-2012-2-semenova-Continuities_in_the_formation_of.pdf?sequence=1

This was covered in various Richwicks threads where he brought up the usual Critical Religion Theory, then grudgingly acknowledge he didn't know, then assert it again in later threads.

Also mentioned previously was the proportion of the vote for Communist groups in Interwar Poland.

With Jews being unique among all voters (including the Polish Catholic majority!) in overwhelming preference for the "Nationalist" Center-right (Grand Marshal Pilsudski) with the other Minorities preferring either local ethnic parties or Communist
https://cpb-us-e2.wpmucdn.com/faculty.sites.uci.edu/dist/9/994/files/2021/05/who_voted_communist.pdf



For CRT, the cause of the West's Decline isn't the Enlightment, the French Revolution, the Scientific Revolution, etc. but World War One. However, CR Theorists dismiss the Kaiser's policy of confrontation and escalation that he adopted his entire reign from the firing of Bismarck which contributed much to WW1, and studiously ignores the financing of Lenin by the Kaiser's Army High Command (the Russian Liberals being not willing to sign Peace in the East with the minimum concessions the Germans desired)

As always more debates is the answer. I look forward to Darryl Cooper eventually accepting Andrew Roberts invitation.

Patrick says

.

Various AI responses say Jews represented 1.5% of the Russian population and 20% of the Bolshevik leadership were Jews.

AI responses say to be cautious to associate the Jews motivation to ethnic and religious agendas, as they were motivated by political ideology.

But the culture may promote Bolshevism if it is centered on a victim mentality or fighting for the oppressed by any means necessary.

.

Patrick says

I'm pretty sure it's true.

https://www.unz.com/pub/jhr__the-jewish-role-in-the-bolshevik-revolution-and-russias-early-soviet-regime/

Do we have a source for the quoted image? Title of the book or publication it came from?

MisdemeanorRebel says

The problem with race is that is obsfucates Culture with physical characteristics. The PoMos deliberately confound the two in an attempt to weaken Western Civilization by trying to create an apparent paradox with Western Principles that doesn't actually exist.

ALL PoMos, including the "Post-Liberals" "Woke Right" (or Right Socialism or Critical Religion Theorists)

PanicanDemoralizer says

Do we have a source for the quoted image? Title of the book or publication it came from?

The below came up in Google search.

"The Times" of London published an article on March 29, 1919, that made the claim you've cited regarding the number of Jews among Bolshevist leaders. The article stated that "of the 20 or 30 commissaries, or leaders who provide the central machinery of the Bolshevist movement, not less than 75 per cent are Jews... among the minor officials the number is legion".

.

https://dn790006.ca.archive.org/0/items/judaismandbolshevism_201907/Judaism%20and%20Bolshevism.pdf

My post above is from the above link which is a reprint from the Catholic Herald , November 4, 1933

.

AD says

https://dn790006.ca.archive.org/0/items/judaismandbolshevism_201907/Judaism%20and%20Bolshevism.pdf

My post above is from the above link which is a reprint from the Catholic Herald , November 4, 1933

Thanks for that - Wow, Hitchens really nailed it. But I was looking for Patrick's image with the numbers from his post if I was unclear:

Patrick says

PanicanDemoralizer says

Thanks for that - Wow, Hitchens really nailed it. But I was looking for Patrick's image with the numbers from his post if I was unclear:

I did an image search for the image that Patrick posted with the Bolshevik stats but nothing came up and it was a dead end search such as to the below website. But I posted what I did as it was the closest info source I could find that supported Patrick's post.

https://vaticancatholic.com/how-many-jews-were-in-the-bolshevik-administration-that-took-control-of-russia/

,

@AD thanks for that!

Most Holy Family Monastery, haven't heard about them in a while. I think they're up in New England somewhere, sedevacantist sect. They used to advertise on Radio/TV now and again sometime in the 90s.

EDIT: Yep, same one, recognize the farm.

They think John Paul II is antiChrist and not a real Pope, or anybody since Vatican II.
https://vaticancatholic.com/large-statue-of-antipope-john-paul-ii-outside-of-gemelli-hospital/