0
0

RealtyTrac, CoreLogic Confirm Housing Bear Thesis: 85-90% of REOHeld Off Market


 invite response                
2013 Jan 27, 12:03pm   25,326 views  68 comments

by HousingBoom   ➕follow (1)   💰tip   ignore  

RealtyTrac, CoreLogic Confirm Housing Bear Thesis: 85-90% of REO Being Held Off Market, Meaning “Tight” Inventories Are Bogus

http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2012/07/realtytrac-corelogic-confirm-housing-bear-thesis-85-90-of-reo-being-held-off-market-meaning-tight-inventories-are-bogus.html#5y9tQYtW81UaISZe.99

#housing

« First        Comments 12 - 51 of 68       Last »     Search these comments

12   varmint   2013 Jan 28, 8:29am  

Philistine says

It's stunning how many foreclosures are in central LA right now. 90% of what's on the market. I'm sure they'll all get bought up by cash flippers and put back on the market for 20% more than comps.

Depends.

I would imagine stuff getting foreclosed this late in the game has LTV >> 100% so it won't sell at auction. Minimum bid is typically the amount owed on the house.

Once they go REO they'll be priced at market so there's probably not a lot there for flippers depending on how much prices have already risen in your area.

13   RealEstateIsBetterThanStocks   2013 Jan 28, 10:53am  

here's the location massive shadow inventory. have a look:

http://www.youtube.com/embed/3i3z1njpCnY

14   RentingForHalfTheCost   2013 Jan 28, 10:59am  

Raw says

underwaterman says

Let me make a prediction: Soon you will have the permabulls in the thread here denying reality, ignoring it, or distorting this article and it's risks. They will outnumber the people actually reading the article by 3 to 1.

So far al I see is the perma bears. Anyone who listened to them a year ago are sorry as hell.

Sorry why? Because now they have all their wealth in the virtual home equity, that is about as reliable as getting a nice sleep next to the giant printing press of this country. Money anyone? Here is a truck for everyone. Now lets go spend it on housing cause that will make you rich. Go boys and girls, help this country out of the pit.

15   David9   2013 Jan 29, 1:11am  

Raw says

So far al I see is the perma bears. Anyone who listened to them a year ago
are sorry as hell.

I'm not 'sorry as hell'. What? Let's see, I could have had:
(All are plural)

1.) Condos that look onto other people's property
2.) Condos that look onto stucco walls
3.) Condos that need $money$ plus mortgage to be liveable.
4.) Condos that that are investor flips
5.) Condos with high HOA fees

Basically, I could have bought the bank's sh*t, or given my equity to an investor.

16   Shaman   2013 Jan 29, 1:22am  

Yes. Those have been the options here too. Buy property in bad location or tiny and overpriced. Or the investor flips which can sell for 10% more than normal.
All options suck for home buyers right now. The market is so bogus if you buy something now you should pay for it with $3 bills.

17   Shaman   2013 Jan 29, 1:34am  

Thanks Obama, it's because of you and your bankster puppeteers that I've lost all hope of owning my own home.
I guess I'm not poor enough or lazy enough to deserve a seat at the table.
F---!

18   Facebooksux   2013 Jan 29, 1:42am  

FUCK YOU BERNANKE!!!1

19   varmint   2013 Jan 29, 2:48am  

robertoaribas says

obviously, you don't know anything about foreclosures then. The bank doesn't usually set the minimum bid at the debt owed, or NOTHING would ever get bought at auction; they have have done that in 2006, but they learned. They estimate the value it will sell for. Right now, about 50% are purchased, 50% go back to the bank

Ever think that it's more advantageous for the bank to not sell at auction? Smaller pool of buyers (in CA you need 100% cash on the steps) who will be risk adverse due to no inspections etc.

Yes some are discounted from amount owed but from what I've followed, most are not. I'm sure this depends on the specific market and how much REO the bank is willing/able to take on.

What's true for you in AZ is not necessarily what's true for someone else in CA. As for your tone: get fucked.

20   varmint   2013 Jan 29, 4:55am  

thank you, this data is more helpful than insults

21   Raw   2013 Jan 29, 8:18am  

Quigley says

Thanks Obama, it's because of you and your bankster puppeteers that I've lost all hope of owning my own home.

I guess I'm not poor enough or lazy enough to deserve a seat at the table.

F---!

Obama and Bernanke had a job to do....Get the housing market and the economy back on the path to recovery. They have achieved this with flying colors, and undoubtedly deserve praise, not criticism.
Many home buyers who did not see the bounce in housing coming have missed the boat, but that should not stop anyone from jumping onto the next boat which will come along.

22   Raw   2013 Jan 29, 8:20am  

David9 says

Raw says

So far al I see is the perma bears. Anyone who listened to them a year ago

are sorry as hell.

I'm not 'sorry as hell'. What? Let's see, I could have had:

(All are plural)

1.) Condos that look onto other people's property

2.) Condos that look onto stucco walls

3.) Condos that need $money$ plus mortgage to be liveable.

4.) Condos that that are investor flips

5.) Condos with high HOA fees

Basically, I could have bought the bank's sh*t, or given my equity to an investor.

No mention of $100,000 gain in equity you could have had? I find it hard to believe you would not want it.

23   David9   2013 Jan 29, 8:35am  

Raw says

No mention of $100,000 gain in equity you could have had? I find it hard to
believe you would not want it.

Of course I want that. Why do you think I bitch and complain so much ?

In the low end open market, that much of an equity gain is not a reality.

Now, if I was a cash investor at the courthouse steps..

You betcha ;-)

24   inflection point   2013 Jan 29, 11:58am  

Raw,

The job Ben Bernanke and Obama (and Bush) had to do was rob honest citizens of their hard earned savings and their future. They are no better than Bernie Madoff. The only advantage they have over Bernie is they have the law on their side.

25   inflection point   2013 Jan 29, 12:54pm  

Robert,

You going to bet the farm on a sample of 20? Oh by the way, does the series "property wars" make you feel better or worse about your investments? No sarcasm just a question.

26   yup1   2013 Jan 29, 1:17pm  

robertoaribas says

DESPITE what nitwits misstate about accounting, publicly traded banks are
actually required to report the number of loans 30/60/90 days late or in
foreclosure. The numbers get put out there. Ditto all of the credit reporting
agencies which within a couple weeks or so, get mortgage delinquency notices on
every type of bill not paid on time, including mortgages. These statistics have
all improved remarkably for Arizona and California over the past year.

Go read Calculated risk or LPS if you want to see the actual numbers not your anecdotal evidence. LPS report shows 5.6 Million homes in foreclosure or delinquent. That is a fact. The banks DO NOT have to issue a notice of default at 90 days, they can. Do you want anecdotal evidence. Here are some homes in my neck of the woods.

http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/1111-La-Sierra-Dr-El-Dorado-Hills-CA-95762/18594431_zpid/

Notice of Default January 10, 2013. $135,209 past due. That is much greater than 90 days late.

http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/8029-Marches-Way-El-Dorado-Hills-CA-95762/59929320_zpid/

Notice of default March 2011. $41,579 past due. Foreclosure auction 1 year and 10 months later.

Now you will say I cherry picked a couple places but I could literally link homes all day that are in this same condition. There are 2040 homes in Mesa, AZ that are up for foreclosure auctions.......

27   yup1   2013 Jan 29, 1:22pm  

robertoaribas says

in fact ALL THE DATA says their isn't any real shadow inventory, and all the
shadow believers ever have is, "I drive around and see empty homes..." hell my
house might look empty when nobody is home. People go on vacation too. rentals
sit empty in between tenants.... there are vacation homes too.

On my street banks have been trying to sell 2 foreclosed properties for months. They just pulled one from the market, it did not sell. I went and looked in it when they had the open house. It was priced at a 10% premium to another house just up the street. It has at least 35K in work that needs to be done.

Go sign up for zillow if you want to see some of the foreclosure inventory in your area. I repeat SOME because I know that it is not all the inventory. That is a fact.

28   yup1   2013 Jan 29, 1:25pm  

In fact for Zillow they only show homes in Mesa, AZ that are in fact scheduled to be auctioned, they do not show homes that have a Notice of Default. It is so bad that they are even scrubbing the data to remove the date that NOD was issued.

29   varmint   2013 Jan 30, 2:20am  

robertoaribas says

Also, to be honest, that is a shockingly high rate of cancellations, and if I were considering buying in California, I'd investigate that further.

I looked in the zip where I am specifically searching and the cancellation rate was over 80% for the last few months. I've been scouring the listing pretty hard in this area and recall only one or two short sales over that period.

I think they're putting them off, which makes sense for the bank because prices are rising. Or maybe a ton of people are getting loan mods /shrug

30   David9   2013 Jan 30, 2:32am  

I like this analogy from 2012:

"“Picture a monotonously stormy and foggy day. The rain is pouring..not just down, but sideways and upside down and swirling. It’s so dark, you can’t see six feet in front of you. And right in the middle of this, you’re barreling down the interstate at 100 mph. The water across the highway is so deep that you’re just hydroplaning and twisting and flying straight off the road. And more and more people just keep getting on that interstate, going faster and faster. After hours and hours of this the entire roadway is a scene of carnage and destruction. Bodies and mangled cars lying everywhere. And still the cars just keep on coming. Faster, harder, more of them.
Law enforcement and highway patrol are totally aware of the carnage on the road, but they do absolutely nothing. Worse, they stand there flagging more and more cars onto the interstate…”KEEP ‘EM MOVING!” , “GET IN THERE!” , “GO FASTER!” They shout.
Now, instead of cars on the interstate, understand that this is what’s happening with homes in foreclosure. The banks haven’t even begun to clean up the existing wreckage, but they’re throwing more carnage into the pipelines just as fast as they can spit foreclosure lawsuits out of their computers.
And the best part about all this societal carnage is the victims, the American taxpayer, are paying for all this.
Welcome to Amerika 2012!"

And this explanation of title:

"“A single mortgage may involve several banks or companies — one that made the loan; another that “services” the loan by collecting payments; and another that funnels payments to yet another bank, or “trustee,” that disburses proceeds from mortgage payments to investors of loans bundled together as mortgage-backed securities.
Add to that the recent wave of bank closures and mergers, and you’ve often got a jumble of corporate entities.
Towns have struggled to unravel this chain of relationships to force the banks to act.
“It’s a legal nightmare to figure out who is responsible,” said Raquel Diaz, code compliance manager for Lake Worth.
For example, a house may be titled to “Deutsche Bank c/o Saxon Mortgage Services Company.” Deutsche Bank is a German firm that acts as a “trustee.”
SUN SENTINEL"

Anyone recommend buying top dollar California Real Estate in a shrinking economy?

31   David9   2013 Jan 30, 6:07am  

underwaterman says

Playing in the housing manipulated market is pure gambling. Much better to sit
it out until it deleverages from debt to inventory.

I couldn't agree more.

Even this article states of the danger of an 'asset bubble' from all the Fed pumping.

http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/01/30/us-usa-fed-idUSBRE90T0TF20130130

And someone today at work came up with: "Who would buy a house now, they have to pay double, once with the mortgage and then again with their taxes for all the stimulus"

32   David9   2013 Jan 30, 7:13am  

robertoaribas says

you pay the tax stimulus REGARDLESS of whether you own a home or not...

Yep. But I found it interesting and post worthy that someone who probably does not follow patrick.net would come up with that statement.

33   postbubblesucess   2013 Jan 30, 7:16am  

Trulia says my property went up 17.4% since last January. It was confirmed when my neighbor who bought 10 months ago sold his property 2 weeks ago for $47.5k. He bought for $38k and spent a lil too much in remodeling, but it looks nice. Mine was $43.5k and I've spent $3k remodeling. It's beautiful and wouldn't let it go for anything less than $52k at this point. My plan is to either rent it out or sell when it reaches $65k in a few years maybe sooner. After the next Bubble in about 5 years I'll buy again. Maybe the same place for $25k. Just some of the thoughts going through my head. What do you guys think?

34   David9   2013 Jan 30, 7:21am  

postbubblesucess says

What do you guys think?

Yes ! Just because I and others have not found or pounced on a possible flip here in California does not mean YOU cannot profit from this .. market !

35   RealEstateIsBetterThanStocks   2013 Jan 30, 7:30am  

postbubblesucess says

Trulia says my property went up 17.4% since last January. It was confirmed when my neighbor who bought 10 months ago sold his property 2 weeks ago for $47.5k. He bought for $38k and spent a lil too much in remodeling, but it looks nice. Mine was $43.5k and I've spent $3k remodeling. It's beautiful and wouldn't let it go for anything less than $52k at this point. My plan is to either rent it out or sell when it reaches $65k in a few years maybe sooner. After the next Bubble in about 5 years I'll buy again. Maybe the same place for $25k. Just some of the thoughts going through my head. What do you guys think?

investors are still buying and inventory is still low. i would hold if i were you. prices are expected to go up this year.

36   HEY YOU   2013 Jan 30, 11:14am  

New title for the link:
The Bulls are full of Bullshit.

37   David9   2013 Jan 31, 1:15am  

It's like a twilight zone nightmare.

Again, like every morning, something interesting comes up, then after 10 seconds I find the catch.

Nice unit + location. $558 HOA ? Um, that's every month..

http://www.redfin.com/CA/Sherman-Oaks/4536-Colbath-Ave-91423/unit-11/home/4854008?utm_source=myredfin&utm_campaign=listings_update&utm_medium=email

38   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 4:20am  

robertoaribas says

yup1 says



If Roberto is wrong that bitch is all in and will get killed. I hope that he is wrong and gets crushed.


yeah, that jealousy thing is going to eat you alive!
Units I bought for 31.5K are now selling for over 70K, it would take a hell of a crash to bring me back to "just breaking even" let alone getting killed. Add in 2 years rent on that unit, and whatever... I could throw that one away, and it would have cost me less than the five years I owned a bmw m3 convertible!

We all know your story Roberto. If we crash again you will be liquidating just like most investors do.

By the way that graph you linked of Phoenix looks like a Dead Cat Bounce!

39   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 4:27am  

The stress in the Phoenix rental market will also get much much worse. Rents will come down. Investors will drop rents as they compete for renters with more and more available rentals. Hell in some price ranges nearly 90% of rentals posted on Craigslist allow pets. In healthier markets that number is below 40%. This to me is a huge sign of stress. Desperate landlords will eventually allow methlabs as long as the rent gets paid. It is simple supply and demand, Roberto. Massive rental supply with almost no increase in demand will lead to lower prices both for rent and for homes.

40   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 4:29am  

robertoaribas says

since 9 of my homes are free and clear, not sure how even someone as
dimwitted as you thinks I'll be forced to liquidate!

Now why if you believe what you say you believe would you own 9 rentals free and clear? You wouldn't you would cash out refi and buy more rentals. With that statement you prove that you are full of shit.

41   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 4:54am  

robertoaribas says

since 9 of my homes are free and clear, not sure how even someone as
dimwitted as you thinks I'll be forced to liquidate!

Link them!

42   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 5:47am  

robertoaribas says

If you weren't a complet dumbass, you'd know that cash-out refi of investment
properties, past 4 is impossible. Or else, I would... you really like calling
people "full of shit" or "liar" in real life, we know you are a pathetic
coward...

A search of your dumbass on Maricopa County shows since 01/01/2007 you have 8 Trust Deeds with your name on them totaling 999K. You need to do some explaining........

43   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 5:50am  

I can link all of the PDF's if you want. Like I said before if there is a downturn you are FUCKED!

44   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 6:04am  

You can look it up yourself

http://recorder.maricopa.gov/recdocdata/

Ribas
Robert
Deed of Trust
begin search 01/01/2007

45   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 6:08am  

robertoaribas says

a couple of refi's in there, so your off by a bit... Now, be a good boy, look up all the the home values :-)

A couple? 8 is not a couple it is at least a few. 999K holy fuck that is a lot of DEBT!

46   PockyClipsNow   2013 Jan 31, 6:10am  

You guys bashing roberto are jealous of his success. Very juvenile. Would be smarter to learn from him he knows his $hit.

47   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 6:15am  

PockyClipsNow says

You guys bashing roberto are jealous of his success. Very juvenile. Would be smarter to learn from him he knows his $hit.

Except for the fact that his FACTS are not FACTS! So you can learn from someone who distorts FACTS if you think that is wise.....

48   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 6:19am  

robertoaribas says

a couple of refi's in there, so your off by a bit... Now, be a good boy, look up all the the home values :-)

I see no Release of these deeds of trust which means yup you owe someone else 999K.

Secondly I do not see your name on 14 properties in Maricopa county since 01/01/2007. Now I guess you could own properties from pre 01/01/2007 but that would mean that you are very likely upsidedown on them........

49   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 6:26am  

I see the release so 775K.

I do not see your name on 14 properties post 01/01/2007?

50   yup1   2013 Jan 31, 6:33am  

yup1 says

I see the release so 775K.


I do not see your name on 14 properties post 01/01/2007?

I already corrected where I was wrong. Why is your name not on 14 properties like you claim?

51   David9   2013 Jan 31, 6:39am  

Wanted to place laughing icon here, didn't work.

Entertaining thread this afternoon...

« First        Comments 12 - 51 of 68       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions