0
0

Lamentations on the rental housing stock


               
2007 May 20, 6:49pm   19,289 views  188 comments

by e   follow (0)  

typical Redwood City neighborhood

One of the reasons that Realtors and other housing bulls frequently cite as a "positive" for buying is that you'll end up living in a better place.

Now, let's ignore for a minute the fact that it would cost you $585,000 to buy a 560 sqft [sic] house that rents for $1850 a month. And that doesn't include the pit bulls and ADT monitoring you'll need.

The fact is that the rental stock is pretty not-so-great around here. I spent most of this weekend looking at apartments to rent in Redwood City, and nothing I saw was particularly a fantastic bang for the buck. In fact, most of the things I saw made me wonder if I would hear a bang go off and into my gut for a buck.

Even the most expensive place in 94063 (Franklin Street Apartments) has a problem with crime apparently. In fact, the reviews of most places in Redwood City simply leave me shaking my head.

What gives? All I want is an apartment that's a min of 750 sqft, 1-2br, with a covered parking spot, that's somewhat close to both 92 and 85, and where I won't be a victim of crime. I'm even close to giving up my quest to find a place that has washer/dryer in unit.

Am I really asking for too much? Too demanding?

Do I really need to buy a place to meet this criteria?

#housing

Comments 1 - 30 of 188       Last »     Search these comments

1   e   @   2007 May 20, 7:09pm  

Oh yeah, I'd also appreciate it if my nicer car didn't get stolen on the first day of living there. Apparently that's a recurring theme in Redwood City.

Which apparently has YoY increases in crime:

http://www.city-data.com/city/Redwood-City-California.html

2   Randy H   @   2007 May 20, 11:47pm  

The nicer rentals in RWC are not in the flat near ECR. Rent a small 2BR house -- there are lots of those in the neighborhoods near ADLP between Edgewood and Woodside. Or look at apartments in the 280 corridor.

If you're really wanting to stay closer to El Camino, then look at San Carlos or Belmont to the north or Menlo to the south. There are a ton of condos/townhouses usually renting in Menlo east of ECR, and in a lot lower crime area than RWC.

3   skibum   @   2007 May 21, 1:41am  

Shouldn't the correct location for this post be in Craigslist, under "housing wanted"?

I'd second Randy - there are nice places in Menlo Park just off Ravenswood east of El Camino. Noel St. and the surrounding area. There are also pockets of condos, some of which may be rentals, near 280 in San Carlos. Near downtown San Mateo is nicer than downtown RWC, too.

4   astrid   @   2007 May 21, 2:17am  

My boyfriend rents in Pleasanton and from what I can tell, almost all the apartment stock there are decent to rather nice. Never had any burglary issues.

5   Eliza   @   2007 May 21, 3:08am  

I'd suggest trying a different methodology--I'm not sure how you are searching for a place to live, but try something else. Craigslist is pretty good. Actually, local newspapers can also be pretty good--older folks who own just one rental property tend to post in newspapers rather than going through a service or posting on the net. And older folks with just one rental property make very nice landlords, generally speaking--pay your rent on time, make arrangements for maintenance, and they will treat you like gold.

You might also want to avoid apartment complexes if you can. A condoplex with a few rentals will do you better, as will a single family home.

This is a weird thread. Can we have another?

6   Listening   @   2007 May 21, 3:15am  

Congratulations,
Nine on topic posts in a row (on a housing blog). Let's count how many there will be befpre it degenerates into a High School-esque blabbing about boyfriends and shallow lives.

7   FormerAptBroker   @   2007 May 21, 3:24am  

DAiryQUeen Says:

> I knew a frustrated guy who couldn’t rent a
> decent place for $5,000 in the city. Instead,
> he paid 33% over asking in the HAIGHT for
> this nice SFH for $2 mil. WOW.

Sounds like a great deal!!

For only about $15,000 (PITI + Maint) a month the guy has a nice looking older home in the Hayes Valley where he is just steps from gang members selling crack in the housing projects, drunk homeless guys in Buena Vista park and heroin addicted homeless teens who walk up and down Haight on a regular basis…

8   Randy H   @   2007 May 21, 3:36am  

DAQU

Don't skirt the issue. Have you stacked up some colored wooden blocks and taught yourself how a "median" works yet?

9   EBGuy   @   2007 May 21, 3:51am  

eburbed,

Put your destiny in your own hands. I'm sure you can find someone else who would like an "affordable" house. Make your own condo (secure parking included!).
$975000 Two seperate homes on one lot (redwood city)

10   Malcolm   @   2007 May 21, 4:07am  

justapeon Says:
May 21st, 2007 at 10:15 am
Congratulations,
"Nine on topic posts in a row (on a housing blog). Let’s count how many there will be befpre it degenerates into a High School-esque blabbing about boyfriends and shallow lives. "

Didn't this post break that chain?

11   Malcolm   @   2007 May 21, 4:16am  

You guys are really getting creative with the graphics. That's funny.

12   monkeyinchief   @   2007 May 21, 4:18am  

Renting on the Peninsula is miserable. It's hard to find a decent place to live. I moved last year and the search was just awful. You do get a better place if you buy but the premium is ridiculous.

The rental stock is really poor because except for luxury apartments it's a financially irrational decision for the landlord to rent property. For single family houses or small plexes, the rental income pales in comparison to the market value of the property. It makes more sense to sell the place and invest elsewhere. The true believers who are willing to rent for rental income at 2-3% of property value are not going to be upgrading the units to something decent. When you have a business that has negative economic returns (essentially accounting profits - cost of capital) it makes zero sense to put in additional capital.

I think this logic applies to even large apartment buildings since they could be sold to developers who will replace the apartment structure with condos. There maybe zoning problems to doing the conversion but the negative returns on capital to improve the apartment building still holds.

The absurd rental price to purchase price to ratio means renting is miserable since the only the irrational rent. The problem is exacerbated if you are looking to rent a single family home because an sane landlord with a SFH should sell it.

I hope to leave the Bay Area next year. I believe I will be able to substantially improve my standard of living by moving to an area where the real estate market is less crazy.

13   e   @   2007 May 21, 4:20am  

Actually, local newspapers can also be pretty good–older folks who own just one rental property tend to post in newspapers rather than going through a service or posting on the net.

Whoa... a newspaper. I'd never thought of that. Will have to give it a try!

Having spent all of my time here in the Bay Area living in Santa Clara, I'm really surprised than San Mateo is so blah.

14   astrid   @   2007 May 21, 4:23am  

Screw high school, let's talk high end chef's knives.

15   Listening   @   2007 May 21, 4:31am  

"really want to belong to the “in-crowd”

Please stop! I just sprayed my milk all over the desk.

I grew up on the peninsula and even managed property there for 8 years.
There is very little "IN" there anymore. Trader Joes.....puleeese. Eating at overpriced eateries, naaah.

The only thing slightly cool are the kiters on the NE side of the San Mateo bridge.

To keep this topical. My advice: Get the lowdown from other residents on how well a place is renting and then play hardball.

16   Listening   @   2007 May 21, 4:33am  

NW side

17   sfbubblebuyer   @   2007 May 21, 4:41am  

Finding a good rental place on the peninsula does suck... but it sure sucks less than house hunting. I've seen several places I'd be interested in renting, and none that don't make me sick to my stomache at the idea of buying (at anything near the prices they're asking.)

18   DinOR   @   2007 May 21, 4:43am  

Great graphic! Is that Manila or Miami? Any time I see corrugated sheet metal roofing I automatically think Manila.

As FAB notes just b/c you're willing to throw borrowed $'s around is no assurance you won't be rubbing elbows with the wrong crowd anyway. The difference is the renter can pull up his/her tent stakes at the first sign of lawlessness, can the loan-owner?

Since any discussion of RE is in ways a discussion about life or lifestyle in general, it can be hard to seperate the two. I find when posters include some of their personal insights and preferences it gives me a better understanding of what motivates people. Not boring at all.

19   HARM   @   2007 May 21, 4:59am  

@DinOR,

Good guess, but that would be Thailand.

20   EBGuy   @   2007 May 21, 5:02am  

I remember seeing on Ben's blog that some folks post their "renter's resume" on Craiglist to good effect. They ended up getting replies from landlords offering them places for LESS than they were posted in the "For Rent" section of Craiglists. This, of course, is predicated on the poster being a "desirable tenant".

MonkeyInChief... Nice price to rent ratio rant. Thankfully, there are folks like FABs parents to help keep the market honest (and mess with the FBs trying to rent out their places).

21   DinOR   @   2007 May 21, 5:07am  

I stand corrected. Lovely view!

About six months ago a poster brought to our attention that one of the great sources for rentals in the BA are open houses. Simply enjoy the free wine, get the realtor on the side and ask them, "Do you think they would consider renting it out?"

I can't remember who, but they said they had never heard an out and out NO! Just a thought.

22   e   @   2007 May 21, 5:46am  

You did not mention if you were single or had a family

Good point - this is for 2.

23   hugel   @   2007 May 21, 6:17am  

Monkey In Chief,

I have had the same idea of moving out of bay area. Brought up the idea of Austin, Texas with Mrs a few times. At the beginning I was always shut down with "You are crazy". Then after I put down the real hard math that we easily pay off a brand new 3000 sq ft home and have only one of us work, I can slowly see how she's also seeing the real craziness of owning here.

Anthony

24   DinOR   @   2007 May 21, 6:19am  

"I was going to guess Soweto"

The lack of Marlboro billboards should have told me it wasn't Manila? What I've found on Craigslist is that often FSBO listings that are "for sale" can also be found in the "homes for rent" section as well. Apparently hopeful sellers were trying not to tip their hand that the market isn't as white hot as their potential GF might believe.

Of late I've seen a lot of fluff that's available for sale, for rent or lease w/ option to buy all in the same posting. Take my wife.... please! Ta-dump.

25   e   @   2007 May 21, 6:38am  

What I’ve found on Craigslist is that often FSBO listings that are “for sale” can also be found in the “homes for rent” section as well.

Here I think it's not as obvious. The for sale/for rent house I linked to in the original post at the top was only caught because I had seen it previously, and in real life as well.

26   DinOR   @   2007 May 21, 7:10am  

eburbed,

I agree. Although I will add that 2 years ago, it wasn't that obvious in Las Vegas either. You really had to be a "student of the market" to have caught it then, now? No thing at all. It'll get there.

OT, another crappy spring in OR. My neighbor went to Mexico and asked if I wouldn't mind watering. I assured him... no problem (and it hasn't been). :(

27   EBGuy   @   2007 May 21, 7:33am  

Speaking of Craigslist, the Bay Area ReduceOMeter hit an all time high of 198 "reduced" listings for May 18-19. So the tsunami is growing in the outer burbs.... will be interesting to see how big (or small) it is when it hits the "fortress".

28   simcha   @   2007 May 21, 7:45am  

Hi folks. It's been a while. I've been through two surgeries to try to slow down my heartbeat. Both failed but they've found medicine to keep my heart rate under control.

Anyway, my Mother came to take care of me through it all. I got out of the hospital on the first anniversary of my Father's death. My Mother's been wanting me to move back to the Chicago area for years. I've been here about five years. The thing is after visiting here with me she sees that I actually have a life here, while spartan.

She has recently suggested that she and my Brother (who lives on disability) might want to move out here to Oakland with me. My Mother asked me to research 3 bedroom houses to rent in the Oakland Area. My research revealed some really interesting possibilities. The decent neighborhoods offer places in the $2000-$3000 range. We have to rent a place that would allow us to keep cats. My Brother and I have a cat each. We all know that makes renting more difficult.

Anyway, I've tried to advise her to stay put. She's paid off her house and pays property taxes and association fees of around $375 per month. She's not well off but she does have a decent retirement income from Dad's state pension plus negligible investments from his life insurance policy and IRAs. She could afford to split rent with my Brother and I.

Eesh! I can't believe I'm even considering living with my Mother and Brother. My Mom's a widow and my Brother and I have never been married. I'm 37, my Brother's 35, and my Mom's 63. She's got a lot of life left, so I would think. Dad died unexpectedly last year at only 64 so who knows. (His Dad is living in Southern California and is 88 years old. We're usually long-lived.)

Beyond the concern of all of us living under one roof again, I'm concerned that my Mother isn't considering what's best for her finances. She's thinking with her heart and her loneliness and concern for me. I've tried to explain to her that this is the last place a retired person should move to because of the cost of living.

One consideration though, as she ages she'll need care. It's bound to happen, it happens to all of us. I would rather live close to her whenever this time comes because I know I'd want to participate in her care. I don't want her shipped off to some nursing home unless her care became way too complicated for me or my Brother.

Well, I'm kind of off subject, but I really wanted to let people know that there are decent rentals at decent prices out there, even if you have pets. I know that my building is close to full occupancy though. I've noticed that we have fewer and fewer vacancies, so perhaps that is changing.

It seems that my part of the East Bay is a good place to rent still. It's a much better fincancial proposition than owning in Oakland, that's for sure....

29   simcha   @   2007 May 21, 7:49am  

Sorry about the double post. IT didn't post so I tried again. Please delete the first post above.

30   HARM   @   2007 May 21, 7:50am  

For those of you who are curious about the whole Nigel/Casey/RobDawg thing, check out: http://www.caseypedia.com/wiki/Main_Page.

And remember, itsallgood™...

Comments 1 - 30 of 188       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste