0
0

Bouncing Dead Cats


               
2006 Oct 23, 2:17am   14,817 views  126 comments

by Randy H   follow (0)  

Dead Cat
Plateau, pause, recovery, "bear trap"? Maybe it's just a good, old fashioned, "dead cat bounce".

The technical reasons usually given for such false recoveries in equity markets have to do with things like short interest, "overbought/oversold" strength conditions, and speculative self-fulfilling prophecy. But everyone knows (except some desperate realtor who write newsletters in SFWoman's neighborhood), the housing market is not the stock market.

The question is, why do you think a "dead cat bounce" could/would/will/is happening in residential real estate?

--Randy H

#housing

« First        Comments 115 - 126 of 126        Search these comments

115   HARM   2006 Oct 24, 6:37am  

Very true…..These loans will soon disappear once Wall Street realizes that they are a very bad investment;they are starting to realize this now.

I hope this happens, I really do. However, I am not so sure it will. If there has been one genuine "new paradigm" to emerge from this monster of a bubble, it's the rise of mortgage-backed securities.

The MBS/CMO revolution is a very real tectonic shift in the way mortgages are financed and the way mortgage risk is being transferred from banks/lenders to individual investors & taxpayers. We must remember that MBS/CMOs are what have made issuing NAAVLPs and I/Os profitable, even with tiny risk premiums, because of that oh-so-critical risk-transferrence. Even the most toxic option-ARM is profitable to the originating lender --in fact, the fees & points (profits) are far HIGHER than they are on originating traditional 15/30-year FRMs or amortizing ARMs.

The new MBS/CMO risk transfer model has been working SO well for lenders that I fear only a complete economic meltdown (resulting from it) would deter banks from voluntarily continuing its use in the future. And, as Randy has pointed out, the current anti-regulation/pro-banking bias in government is so strong, involuntary regulations (with real enforcement) are pretty much out of the question --for now.

I think our best hope where these toxic loans are concerned is that MBS investors eventually begin to recognize that the underlying risk has been severly underpriced and demand greater premiums (which should result in higher mortgage interest rates, which in turn would deter widespread use of toxic loans). Of course, this will require FB defaults on a massive scale, something we could expect to see beginning next year, and continuing in waves for several more years.

116   Peter P   2006 Oct 24, 6:40am  

Very true…..These loans will soon disappear once Wall Street realizes that they are a very bad investment;they are starting to realize this now.

This is like saying:

Bad people will soon disappear once other people realize that they are very bad people.

Do not underestimate human stupidity. Do not overestimate human will.

117   DinOR   2006 Oct 24, 6:47am  

Allah,

A g r e e d....... One of the other things that I noticed was that instead of using these "engineered beams" (which is just wafer board capped by a run of "C" channel) they used FULL dimensional lumber for the main floor joists! Heavy duty stuff too! 6" X 6"? I'm not sure why but apparently there had been some problems with the wafer board beams. In years past they used 2" X 10" @ 16" OC so this looked like a whole new sub-floor system!

118   FormerAptBroker   2006 Oct 24, 6:51am  

Great Chart on:

http://www.oftwominds.com/blog.html

It shows the "false bottom" (where the dead cats bounce)..

119   Peter P   2006 Oct 24, 6:59am  

Have you heard of vigilantism?

What is that?

120   DinOR   2006 Oct 24, 7:11am  

FAB,

"The Plateau of Denial" too funny! Charles does have his moments.

121   skibum   2006 Oct 24, 7:14am  

RE: New vs. old homes, we've lived in both. The old homes seem to be hit or miss. There's probably a tendency towards better construction because the better built homes are the ones that don't fall apart, and in general, tend to stick around longer w/o being torn down. But I've been in plenty of homes in the Boston area that are on their last legs. 18th century farmhouses where everything is sagging, sort of like an 80 year-old woman. Our brownstone in the city was built on pilings above landfill. The pilings require a high water level to prevent rotting, and because of the Big Dig and other construction (the T in particular), that water level has been receding. I remember a story about a guy who woke up one day in his Beacon Hill brownstone and couldn't open the front door. Turns out the house sank and shifted a fair amount overnight because of rotting pilings. On the other hand, the masses of ranches, plywood boxes, stucco boxes in the BA slapped together during the 50's and 60's are certainly not very well built. And McMansions, well those are another story. I doubt those are built to last more than 20 or 30 years. It'll be interesting to see what people do with those a few years down the road. I'd like to see an episode of "This Old House" 20 years from now about rehabbing someone's McAlbatross.

Currently, I'm all for well-designed prefab, or if I have enough resources, new design with a good architect.

122   DinOR   2006 Oct 24, 7:17am  

newsfreak,

I wouldn't mind so much taking on an older home needing "a little" work but that's the problem! There really is no such thing as "a little" work. Once you start digging into things you find, Oh...... they never finished this, completed that and so on. It's not long before you've lost sight of what you were supposed to correct. Now what?

Since I work at home I worry what clients might think if you tell them Oh, don't worry just step on the floor beams! Any remodel looks like the product of a disorganized mind. It just doesn't speak well of you no matter how "sanitized" you go about it.

124   Randy H   2006 Oct 24, 7:18am  

That chart fits exactly with my sticky model. Call it denial, psychology, irrationality, or stickiness. It's all the same thing. Uneven movements downwards.

125   Randy H   2006 Oct 24, 7:19am  

Thanks everyone for your comments on this thread. Not one post had to be moderated or deleted, although CR tested our patience. This thread will now be closed.

126   skibum   2006 Oct 24, 7:20am  

HARM and allah,
RE: MBS's, you guys suggest one resolution is increased compensation for the increasing risk of these products. A more catastrophic yet plausible outcome seems to be the collapse of more than a few hedge funds, or even old-school mutual funds and other investment vehicles due to massive mortgage defaults leading to massive loss in MBS valuations. Possible?

« First        Comments 115 - 126 of 126        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste