0
0

FSBO's: Greedy or Smart?


 invite response                
2006 Jun 1, 4:13am   10,421 views  79 comments

by SQT15   ➕follow (0)   💰tip   ignore  

fsbo

Have you noticed the number of "For Sale By Owner" listings in your neighborhood? Chances are, they're popping up more and more. Websites like FSBO.com and salebyownercalifornia.com are becoming as common as condoflip websites were less than a year ago.

Why is everyone so quick to sell on their own? Is it because they're greedy and don't want to pay the realtorâ„¢ commission fee? Or have the realt-whores finally pi$$ed everyone off?

What's your opinion on the whole thing?

#housing

« First        Comments 40 - 79 of 79        Search these comments

40   tsusiat   2006 Jun 1, 9:21am  

Jon,

I hear you, relative to local Boards offering stuff via WAP/WML, what I meant is, if a site was to arrive that offered the ability to type in something like:

1234 Smith Ave, then could return just lines of addresses, phone numbers, links, maybe maplinks for the same area in realtime, well that could take off.

Replicating stuff meant for larger screens just seems cumbersome.

41   Allah   2006 Jun 1, 9:50am  

People realize their houses value has dropped quite a bit so they figure by selling on their own, they will be able to lower their price that much (realthore's commision) lower than comparables and they may be able to get someone to even look at it!

....but what do I know? The NAR says that RE will appreciate $5.7 percent this year.....duh, my house has been on the market for six months now, duh, nobody is even remotely interested in it, duh, I guess it's time to increase the price 5.7%.

42   astrid   2006 Jun 1, 10:32am  

SFWoman,

Like your ex-neighbor, I'm more than happy to pay more if I can get more. I've seen my share of totally unethical and incompetent agents and they're not just completely worthless, but their presence can actually cost a seller/buyer time by presenting worthless ideas/listings.

43   astrid   2006 Jun 1, 11:22am  

Well, everyone. I'm signing off for a couple weeks with the boyfriend. I promise to keep an eye out for middle of nowhere developments and door to door sale signs. Y'all take care and have fun.

44   surfer-x   2006 Jun 1, 12:36pm  

I have positive proof that the "boom" is over, I went sailing this weekend with a dope smoking $anta Cruz hippy that just "passed" the RE exam. He is slated for millions now. This guy is a waky/bakey dude.

45   Peter P   2006 Jun 1, 1:53pm  

Is the deadline for getting into contract, closing escrow, and registering for school fast approaching? I am seeing a spike of activity for family-sized housing units. However, 2bd homes are just sitting there.

46   Peter P   2006 Jun 1, 2:15pm  

Or another theory is that family-sized units are move-up buyers and priced out first time buyers can’t/aren’t willing to buy the 2 BR units.

Why the spike then?

47   Randy H   2006 Jun 1, 3:14pm  

Sage,

It is for those reasons that I always use a RE attorney to review all documents, regardless of what agents tell me. I have justified the cost in the past by negotiating the commission down by enough "extra" to cover lawyer's fees. I don't have the time or tolerance to do all the legwork myself, as I'd have to do in a FSBO. RE attorneys do represent the person paying them, and not any other interests.

48   Unalloyed   2006 Jun 1, 3:44pm  

Is the US$ being devalued so fast that housing prices are actually falling without the numbers changing much?

49   Randy H   2006 Jun 1, 4:32pm  

Unalloyed

Is the US$ being devalued so fast that housing prices are actually falling without the numbers changing much?

Only if you are a buyer with foreign denominated currency. The value of the USD has nothing to do directly with the value of domestic real estate. In fact, domestic RE represents an asset class for which relative values are not correlated well with things like currencies or stock/bond markets.

All the talk about USD weakness here as it relates to the RE market is of a macroeconomic "side effect" nature. For RE to fall in real terms without nominal prices changes requires domestic inflation. In fact, weakening USD exchange rates work against this because as the USD falls nominal interest rates must rise (because we have a current account deficit), meaning that inflation cannot rise unchecked.*

*Note, this assumes the neocon ZIRP crowd won't get their wet-dream of US inflation operating as a tool of foreign policy. Six years ago I'd have said "never". But at this point just about anything is possible given the lack of leadership on all sides and at all levels.++

++Non partisan statement: I am an equal opportunity cynic.

50   Mike/a.k.a.Sage   2006 Jun 1, 5:34pm  

OT- How many sales to buyers, who actually intended to live in those homes, have been pushed forward in 04 and 05, for fear of being priced out of the market, and for fear of missing out on low interest rates? This must have taken a huge number of potential buyers out of the current market. I think this answers the question of the relator who said, "Where are all the stinking buyers?"

This is a major reason why the bust is hapening sooner rather than later.

51   DinOR   2006 Jun 1, 11:17pm  

Mike/a.k.a Sage,

Well exactly. Several of the articles linked over the last few months clearly stated over HALF of the mortgages in America are under TWO years old! TWO years old! So what, half of America has 28 years (at a minimum) left on their mortgage? That'll sober ya' up in a big hurry.

Not to beat this to death, but had some sort of personal planner been involved, people in their 50's wouldn't be signing up for 30 MORTGAGES! Uh dude, I know, I've heard your 50's are the "new" 30's and I'm down with that and all but when you finally pay this sucka off you'll be in your 80's!

52   DinOR   2006 Jun 1, 11:21pm  

Peter P,

83,000 people took the CFA Exam this cycle. Stop keeping us in suspense and tell us how you did!

53   DinOR   2006 Jun 1, 11:22pm  

Sage,

The horror,

the horror.

54   DinOR   2006 Jun 1, 11:28pm  

Surfer X,

I'll take "waky/bakey" to mean that your sailing "buddy" gets "higher than a Georgia Pine" the very minute he wakes up? Sounds like the kind of guy I want negotiating my "biggest investment"! Oh well, when all else fails there's always real estate.

55   edvard   2006 Jun 2, 12:01am  

Sage,
That's god-awful! I've never heard of such a thing. What the hell was the matter with these people? They'll probably have to spend the rest of their lives paying for that house, so what was the rush? How do crazy people get a loan in the first place?

56   DinOR   2006 Jun 2, 12:02am  

WW2,

Others have commented on the Barret Jackson Auto Auction which is a materialistic tribute to boomers w/money run amok. The bigger question is what could have 300K done for the community?

57   HeadSet   2006 Jun 2, 12:17am  

DinOR,

A comprehensive personal planner for people who do not understand money and investment. A new industry?

Typical advice may be to tell a young couple to limit thier house to one they can pay off in 10 years, invest X in bonds, X in small caps, etc. And of course, no credit card debt that can't be paid off that month.

Got to find a way to stop this planner from recommending investments that pay him bribes, though.

Also, so many Americans are not interested in building real wealth, but in having it now and creating the illusion of prosperity. Witness all the easy credit stores, luxury car leases, and overhocked mini-mansions. They would rather have 6 year car loan on a new BMW rather than own a 2 year old Impala with no loan.

However, I have heard that half the homes in the US have no mortgage, so there is hope!

58   DinOR   2006 Jun 2, 12:37am  

Headset,

You bring up some genuine concerns, and fresh perspectives. My wake up call came as my daughters (18 and 21) began facing the realities of today. We've created a system (Peter P likes to call debt = wealth) that is basically financial suicide. Put in simple terms there are TONS of professionals out there ready willing and able to help you with your investments, taxes and liabilities (insurance) but virtually NO ONE to help young people (or folks in general ) manage their DEBT! It's such a huge hole in the financial services industry you could drive a Mack truck through it! What little we do have is in the form of bankruptcy attorneys, "debt consolidation" services and payday loans for crissakes! We're failing an entire generation (if not two) and somehow managing to live with ourselves. We need to re-examine the whole way we address this issue of debt. Last night I watched the Spelling Bee and have never felt dumber in my life! The words I need to "spell check" would have failed me in round ONE! We have a lot of sharp young people out there and they deserve better.

59   edvard   2006 Jun 2, 12:41am  

Headset,
I was reading an interesting article a few days ago.It is a Harvard report about the mysterious disappearing middle class. It made comparisons between the 1970's and today. One would think that middle class families of today are spending more on stuff, even if inflation is considered, but the stark reality is that compared to the 70's, families are spending LESS. A few reasons are that for one, incomes haven't kept up with inflation. A family in 1975 making the median income level would have as much as 50% of their take home pay leftover for luxury purchases. This was also at a time period when a large number of mothers still stayed home. Small things like clothes, shoes, and other manufactored good were more expensive then than today. Most of those items were still made in the U.S, thus they cost more. The fact is that given inflation, families now make LESS than they did 30 years ago.
A family shopping at Wal-Mart spends way less on consumer goods such as TV's, radios, bicycles, and lawn mowers then people did in the 70's because most of those aforementioned items were considered luxury goods Vs today where except for the extreme euro-chic items, just about all consumer goods are cheap and disposable. Even some of those european brands are all made in Chinese factories right along with the Mr Coffee makers.
The real problem is that until very recently, most metropolitan areas were like the rest of the country and in the middle class bracket. Now that most of these areas are now more favorable to upper income level folks, the economics are not working for the middle class.
This pattern is nothing new. It has been going on for a few decades now. The new " middle class" are those that got their degrees in law, medical, or some other higher learning trade. What's baffling to most middle income folks is that it seems unfathomable that people that make 3-4 times as much as they are at best just barely able to afford what 15 years ago was a plain-jane house.
So in essence, young families are in some ways more responsible with their finances, not because they choose to be, but because the changing economic times has forced them to go into defensive mode. I would probably fit under that category.

60   edvard   2006 Jun 2, 12:51am  

John M,
Honestly, if I had a home that was in California and wanted to sell, I'd probably sell it myself as well. The reason is that I was a salesman for over 7 years. Selling homes is no diffrent than selling power tools or cars. It sounds like you were well aware of the prices around you and priced accordingly.
I don't see that happening in my neighborhood. All I see are people that apparently think that money grows on trees and people will magically appear that will pay the price they demand.

61   DinOR   2006 Jun 2, 1:14am  

John M,

"Most of the FSBO signs down here now are just big lottery tickets..."

LOL! Damn! That's cold man, cold. But totally true! It's been called "throwing you hat in the ring" or a "me too" offering. God, it just makes me ill! John M, you don't know what you've done for me man. Oregonians are the biggest "DIY" crowd on the planet and I've had to look at exponential FSBO sign growth for over a year. There was always something bugging me and now you've put it in total perspective!

62   FormerAptBroker   2006 Jun 2, 1:29am  

willywhopper2 Says:

> Honestly, if I had a home that was in California and
> wanted to sell, I’d probably sell it myself as well.
> The reason is that I was a salesman for over 7
> years. Selling homes is no diffrent than selling
> power tools or cars. It sounds like you were well
> aware of the prices around you and priced accordingly.

This is penny wise and pound foolish thinking...

I'm also a good salesmen (I can overcome objections and close for the sale with the best of them), but since I'm not a full time residential sales person I don't have the contacts to find the agents that work with the buyers that will pay top dollar for my home...

The people that do FSBO home sales are the same kind of people who would post an ad on Craig's List to sell a Picasso (to save the fee art brokers charge)...

63   edvard   2006 Jun 2, 1:33am  

Former Apt Broker,
I totally agree. Just a few years ago, the biggest, baddest, most desireable car to have was a 57' Belair. People ate them up, paying as much as 50k for the things- even the 4 door models. Companies went into business just to make replica parts, and magazines were full of new trim, hoods, door shells, and interior parts.
Everyone bought the things and these days if you head to a Goodguys show, there are so many Belairs, people just don't really care because there isn't anything special about 300 of the same car, in the same color configuration and same boring straight 350 V8. That's why I got a Mercury because most of them were scrapped in the 60's because they had more durable engines for racing. So they wound up being fairly rare for a car of that vintage. Finding parts is near impossible for the body. I've seen maybe 3 other Montereys since owning this one for 4 years. Is it worth anything? Nope. Zilch. In fact, if I sold it now, I would probably lose money on what I've sunk into it.
It's interesting to see what the kiddies fix up these days. Hondas and Acuras complete with big exhaust, cam and engine performance kits, and little trinkety alluminum accessories. In some ways, it's no diffrent than what kids did 30 years ago, which was take some old boring car and hop it up with some monsterous engine. I can respect that, but I can't help but know that in 30-40 years, the old farts walking around car shows will be looking at 91' Honda Civics. Sort of depressing.

64   edvard   2006 Jun 2, 1:36am  

To add, HEMIs are the most overated mechanical item in history. The gimick was simply a hemispherical combustion chamber. woopty-doo.The additional power was neglible. If you want just a classic HEMI engine, expect to pay a minumum of 15-20k. Insane.

65   HeadSet   2006 Jun 2, 2:25am  

WW2

That Harvard report was interesting. What income level do you think they set to be middle class? I presume that would vary greatly by region.

One item that makes that point is aircraft. In the 60's - 70's, one could buy a Cessna 150 for the same price as a new Buick. Every county had a small airport with lots of planes. Average Joe could afford a Cessna or Piper, Rich Joe could buy a Beechcraft or multi-engine. All these plane were made in the good ol' USA. Poor men could afford used planes or rent them cheap.

Today, a new aircraft costs as much as a house in the suburbs. Rental of a Cessna is typically $100/hr, for an old one.

Of course, legalman had something to do with it. In the 80's, Cessna claimed that $20,000 of each new Cessna 152 was to cover assessed legal fees/payouts.

66   DinOR   2006 Jun 2, 2:27am  

John M,

"The loan was completely handled by the builder"

See, this is the type of incestuous relationship that just gets me fuming! Oh, so it must be a "good deal" otherwise the builder wouldn't have handled the whole enchilada! O.K, I gotcha! I have friends and clients (and clients that are friends) doing this kind of thing to me all the time. It just feels so defeating. I have a client that is putting down 150K on a 3 mil. home next week! Oh, I'll provide as directed but I wanted to make sure the guy had plenty of ways to walk away from it. His wire (from another bank) didn't come through in time so the builder's realtor said they now have the right to sell the home to another buyer. Well along comes the builder, tells my client "don't listen to her" and offers the guy 7% on his money! I told my client that the going rate is 8% and half of the profit! Maybe this weekend will chill him out!

67   DinOR   2006 Jun 2, 2:31am  

Headset,

Ever consider a homebuilt? One of my old client's brother puts out an all steel model called the RV 9? They do them right here in Aurora, OR? I think sans powerplant (Lyc. 120) the kit is 20K. Must do alright, his brother tells me he sells a lot of them and they're pop pop popular with enthusiasts. Full aerobatic capability.

68   DinOR   2006 Jun 2, 2:33am  

Headset,

I worked at NAS Cubi Pt. in the "I" and after launching a "floatilla" of F-4 Phantoms a Lycoming 120 may not excite me as much as it used to.

69   HeadSet   2006 Jun 2, 2:49am  

DinOR,

I have been looking at homebuilts on and off through the years, I just have not made the plunge. I will google that RV9, though.

Why wouldn't the Lyco be exciting? If it powers an aerobatic plane, tell me that isn't fun? Are you saying the F4 has spoiled you?

A motorcycle or MG isn't any less fun just 'cause it ain't a Formula One racer

70   DinOR   2006 Jun 2, 3:02am  

Headset,

I've done just about everything one can do with an airplane EXCEPT fly. And I'm O.K with it, really. In truth, yeah I'm pretty spoiled. I was just old enough to see most of the warbirds that served in Nam' get decommssioned. The A-3 Whale (huge), of course the F-4, the F-5 which were used by the Philippine Air Force and many other now obsolete airframes. I worked the "Transient Line" so we had to service/repair just about everything including MAC (C-130/C-141). It was fun b/c everyday was totally different. I had friends at VRC-50 and VC-5 (Adversary Squad. that flew the A-4) and they were hating life. I stay in touch with a lot of those guys and we laugh at how "brainwashed" we still are! Before I complete any work (even if it is on a lawnmower) I still "inventory" my tool box and inspect the area for F.O.D. Sad really.

71   DinOR   2006 Jun 2, 3:08am  

Jon,

"clearly a sign you can't hack it"

That is what's so sad about what we're regrettably conveying to younger people. "Living with enormous amounts of debt dangling over head provides incentive to work and builds character". Really? So I can be a used up character on his 3rd. marriage (and second bankruptcy) just like you dad? What are we doing!

72   Randy H   2006 Jun 2, 3:28am  

new thread Realtors™ Using “Econ” to Push Overpriced Homes

73   HARM   2006 Jun 2, 4:06am  

Being a Gen-Xer, I can’t think of a single domestic car when I was 16-23 that got my blood boiling.

Yeah, I'll second that. I guess if I had to pick one, it would have to be the 300Z. I still remember the cute little nickname for IROCs: Italian Retard Owns Car.

74   DinOR   2006 Jun 2, 4:07am  

Jon,

Yeah, even though I'm in my late 40's I get that assbag garbage too. The bottom line is that I can't change what college costs these days. The only thing I can do about the cost of RE is to complain about here and to anyone that will listen. (But I feel better about it everyday) We've talked my oldest daughter out of buying for now (no dear, we won't be dissapointed if you are not decorating a nursery). The only thing I can do for them is to teach them to absolutely minimize the use of debt leveraging and then show them ways to deal with that debt in a sane an responsible manner. Believe me younger people are not oblivious to the cost of living and if you've got a plan they're open to it!

75   surfer-x   2006 Jun 2, 4:21am  

I bought a '68 RS Camaro convertible from the original owner in 2000 for $6k, kept it 4 years, put about 1K in it and sold it for 14K. The thing is that car is now worth 25K easy. Ahhhh free money from the house ATM. Magic I tell you, and richly deserved. What can I say, either the 30-40 yo crowd waits until the great boomer die off, moves out of state, or resigns oneself to being an indentured servant. The boomers have a full nelson on the housing market/economy and they aren't going to let go until they vi@gra fueled boner goes down. I'm predicting sometime in late 2015, give or take.

76   HeadSet   2006 Jun 2, 4:22am  

ScottC
ScottC

Greetings from total FOOL. I bought 2 houses without an agent several years ago. But then, the sellers had no agents either.

You are assuming buyer's agents work for the buyer. They are typically paid from the seller's commission and thus first and formost are interested in closing the sale. Second is selling the house for as high a price as possible. A buyer's agent is just as likely to work to convince the buyer to "come up" as to convince the seller's agent to get her client to "come down."

77   HeadSet   2006 Jun 2, 4:31am  

I have a Supra Turbo I bought new in 91 and still drive. I think it's nice, but I did not think it would be a classic. I got a good deal on it, since 1991 was when the Savings and Loan collapse occured, and car loans were hard to get. With Joe HowMuchAmonth out of the picture I was able to crank down the dealer price.

I hope something like this happens with houses.

78   HARM   2006 Jun 2, 4:32am  

Welcome back, Scott C.

Funny you should recommend buyers using an agent vs. sellers. The board seems to be running unanimously in the opposite direction: they recommending sellers using an agent, while buyers use a good RE attorney to look over the contract.

I have far less experience than most of the people on this board, many of whom have bought and sold homes several times, but this seems to make more sense to me. I can't really see what value a buyer's agent brings to the transaction, other than take his cut of the 5-6% commission (which of course makes the seller's agent reluctant to steer their clients to you). Both agents don't get paid until a sale is made, and both get paid based on a % of the sale price, so basically BOTH are really representing the seller's interests (getting maximum $$ for the place).

79   HARM   2006 Jun 2, 4:33am  

Posted before I refreshed the screen and saw Headset's reply --we basically said the exact same thing.

« First        Comments 40 - 79 of 79        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions