1
0

Should HOAs be regulated


               
2016 Apr 25, 11:48am   7,555 views  68 comments

by tovarichpeter   follow (7)  

http://www.eastbaytimes.com/breaking-news/ci_29801901/peterson-blackhawk-hoas-heavy-handedness-leads-bigger-conversation

Raise your hand if you have ever lived in a community with a homeowners association. Raise your other hand if you ever wanted to punch your HOA in the nose. That's what I thought. The residents of Blackhawk, the upscale East Bay gated enclave, recently received unsettling news from their HOA: Tidy up your landscaping by June 1 or face "aggressive enforcement" that could result in sanctions ranging from a fine to disabling transponders that open gates to your neighborhood. Where to start? Like a lot of us, some Blackhawkians allowed their lawns to die last summer after Gov. Jerry...

« First        Comments 30 - 68 of 68        Search these comments

31   WookieMan   2025 Aug 21, 7:42am  

Get on the board and put people in their place. Too many people bitch and don't do anything. I'm on a board. It's not fun all the time. You have to be a jerk to people you actually like but have differing opinions. Depends how you handle it.

Overall not a fan of HOA's even though I'm about to be in one in about 30 days. Already attending a meeting. I'll be a dick. Independent but lean libertarian. Get the fuck out of my life.
32   SunnyvaleCA   2025 Aug 21, 10:29am  

HOAs are a little version of government, which means, for the most part, some combination of corrupt and incompetent.

As Dan mentioned above, HOAs attract people with too much time on their hands, which means an extra dose of incompetence... either because they are old (retired and therefore out of touch with the 21st century) or because they are younger but unemployed (because they are so useless as to be unemployable).

Larger forms of government have an extra attraction: career politicians.
33   steverbeaver   2025 Aug 21, 7:14pm  

The version I am familiar with is they contract out to a "property management" firm, and the person who gets money to find flaws in everything suddenly finds flaws in everything, to the point of hallucination / requirements confounding because they may have multiple contracts. The first warning I suggest is to require them to cite the specific contractual line / CC&R or approved guidance that is in breach.

Sorry, no advice to give regarding idle-handed crazy-ladies. They want dick, maybe?
34   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 Aug 21, 8:19pm  

It sucks but if one is in an HOA you have to do politics. People who just want to work and enjoy their property get schlonged by Karens and Kens if they don't participate.
35   HeadSet   2025 Aug 22, 1:56pm  

SunnyvaleCA says

HOAs attract people with too much time on their hands, which means an extra dose of incompetence... either because they are old (retired and therefore out of touch with the 21st century) or because they are younger but unemployed (because they are so useless as to be unemployable).

I must be lucky here. My HOA is only about $500 per year but includes lakes, walking trails, clubhouse, a very nice pool, and a large picnic and playground area with shelters. Enough volunteers for the HOA that we have elections not just for officers, but for committee heads as well. When we had an issue with one of the lake berms, two retired Civil Engineers on the Grounds Committee were able to take care of it. Our HOA Treasurer is an actual CPA. The head of the Trails Committee is a builder and a Scout Master who rebuilt the woodland trail bridges over low spots and streams as a merit badge project for the Scouts. Those bridges are very professional looking treated lumber projects. The HOA President is a younger guy with a good paying job and a hot wife. At the last HOA meeting, this guy was well prepared with a PowerPoint presentation that showed all the issues and what needed to be done. He also had to deal with those members who balked at any spending they thought might increase the HOA fees.
37   WookieMan   2025 Aug 22, 11:10pm  

MolotovCocktail says


WookieMan says


I'm on a board





Why would I dox myself??? I swear you ate paint chips as a kid. But hey, keep posting childish drivel on every thread on this site. You picked up 6 ignores in a little over 2 years. 3 per year Took 12 years for me to get 11. Less than 1 per year. You spam the site daily and I'd say @Patrick is losing potential new users because of it.

Most my ignores are likely also people that don't like my swearing which is understandable. Yours are people annoyed with the constant shit posting of no value. I seriously believe you have mental disorder as I know you post on X. All day every day there and this site and others I'm probably sure you're on. There's medical terms for what you do. You have a mental illness dude and you probably should at least seek out a therapist.

This is why I don't dox myself as you're the type to find my home and do actual harm to me. Sucks because all the other users are chill even when we disagree. You just post shit like the above. What does that add to the site and for other users? Nothing.
38   mell   2025 Aug 23, 4:43am  

HeadSet says

I must be lucky here. My HOA is only about $500 per year but includes lakes, walking trails, clubhouse, a very nice pool, and a large picnic and playground area with shelters. Enough volunteers for the HOA that

Pools and sports courts (we love ours) are great for HOAs to maintain, shifting the liability away from the house owner. Also they often cover roofs and outside walls insurance which lowerd the rates. It's not that different from a voluntarily established commune/small vilage if done right. It can work. Karens are a probmem everywhere, sometimes it gives them something to do and feel useful so they are less of a nuisance if occupied with something unimportant. Just gotta keep that climate change committee at bay
39   MolotovCocktail   2025 Aug 23, 10:06am  

WookieMan says


Why would I dox myself??


With made up bullshit? Easy.

Your credibility on this site is completely shot to hell but you live in this magical imaginary world where you think otherwise.
40   WookieMan   2025 Aug 23, 11:37am  

What have I made up? List 3 with links.
41   MolotovCocktail   2025 Aug 23, 4:33pm  

WookieMan says

What have I made up? List 3 with links.


Why? Plenty right here on this thread. Within the last 7 days in particular.

And you'll just deny it anyway.
42   WookieMan   2025 Aug 23, 4:44pm  

MolotovCocktail says

Why? Plenty right here on this thread. Within the last 7 days in particular.

And you'll just deny it anyway.

What am I denying? You've proven nothing. You assume what I say is a lie and have no proof. That makes you the liar.
43   MolotovCocktail   2025 Aug 25, 3:05pm  

WookieMan says

You've proven nothing.


I see your confusion. YOU provided the proof, but are in denial that you did so. Therefore, you are projecting onto me that I have to provide 'proof' as per your magical reality.
45   RC2006   2025 Sep 1, 4:43pm  

Idaho passed a law that your HOA can't stop you from having chickens if your lot is over a quarter acre.
46   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 Sep 1, 6:08pm  

zzyzzx says


https://www.wptv.com/news/state/florida-lawmaker-floats-ban-on-homeowners-associations-amid-growing-backlash

Florida lawmaker floats ban on homeowners associations amid growing backlash


Realtors are fucking terrified right now, which is why this long overdue reform is finally happening. People simply do not want HOAs, but most builds since the 80s are in HOAs.

It was so bad in FL that HOAs were fining deputy sheriffs and NF Rangers for parking their patrol/work vehicles in their own driveways because their vehicles had "decals and branding" on them.
47   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 1, 6:48pm  

DemoralizerOfPanicans says


zzyzzx says


https://www.wptv.com/news/state/florida-lawmaker-floats-ban-on-homeowners-associations-amid-growing-backlash

Florida lawmaker floats ban on homeowners associations amid growing backlash


Realtors are fucking terrified right now, which is why this long overdue reform is finally happening. People simply do not want HOAs, but most builds since the 80s are in HOAs.

It was so bad in FL that HOAs were fining deputy sheriffs and NF Rangers for parking their patrol/work vehicles in their own driveways because their vehicles had "decals and branding" on them.



I for one don't feel sorry ppl buying into HOAs. Like student loans, nobody put a gun to their heads to sign on the dotted line.

"But...but...everywhere are HOAs if you want to buy a home!" <--- it's like ppl don't fucking read what I wrote or simply cannot accept accountability for their actions. It's still a choice on your part. Everything is a trade off. If you make that choice, you can't bitch about the tyranny of the HOA YOU WILLINGLY SPREAD YOUR BUTTCHEEKS TO. YOU signed on the fucking dotted line.
48   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 1, 6:53pm  

zzyzzx says






So? I'd tell them to fuck off. They have no legal standing to demand anything from you.
49   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 1, 6:55pm  

zzyzzx says

https://www.wptv.com/news/state/florida-lawmaker-floats-ban-on-homeowners-associations-amid-growing-backlash

Florida lawmaker floats ban on homeowners associations amid growing backlash


What about HOAs that maintain streets and water/sewage mains, etc? Yes, for SFHs. Or that isn't common in FL?
50   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 Sep 1, 6:55pm  

Look, 90% of the homes built in Florida in the past 20-30 years are HOAs. Counties encouraged them to save on road maintenance and other costs. But now counties are jacking up taxes like SFBA criminals jack people anyway.

I only own my condo but have zippo intentions of buying a home with any kind of HOA.

The pickings are slim as fuck, though, because of public policy encouraging HOAs.

Glad to see the Realwhores putting their weight behind HOA reform. Mow the lawn, fill the pothole, then shut the fuck up unless people are putting out appliances in the front yard (which is against county regs anyway). Bulldoze the clubhouse and fill the community pool too, would be great.
51   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 1, 6:58pm  

DemoralizerOfPanicans says

Look, 90% of the homes built in Florida in the past 20-30 years are HOAs.


So fucking what? Again:

MolotovCocktail says

"But...but...everywhere are HOAs if you want to buy a home!" <--- it's like ppl don't fucking read what I wrote or simply cannot accept accountability for their actions. It's still a choice on your part. Everything is a trade off. If you make that choice, you can't bitch about the tyranny of the HOA YOU WILLINGLY SPREAD YOUR BUTTCHEEKS TO. YOU signed on the fucking dotted line.
52   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 Sep 1, 6:59pm  

MolotovCocktail says


So fucking what? Again:

Again:

I'm happy HOAs are being restricted and the Socialist Karen-Kens are being defanged and hamstrung
53   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 1, 7:00pm  

DemoralizerOfPanicans says

Again:

I'm happy HOAs are being restricted and the Socialist Karen-Kens are being defanged and hamstrung


Are they? A proposed law is just pandering to voters.
54   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 Sep 1, 7:07pm  

MolotovCocktail says


Are they? A proposed law is just pandering to voters.

A shitload of laws already passed. Addressing everything from conflict of interest/kickbacks to fine limits to mandatory online meeting minutes & mandatory notice of right to pre-fine hearings to restricting the ability of HOAs and NGOs to impose mask requirements. Now more are on the way to further stop KenKarens from pretending they live in an exclusive covenant estate community with properties worth $5M+ apiece and harassing middle class homeowners in modest homes.

https://www.flsenate.gov/Committees/BillSummaries/2024/html/3488#:~:text=The%20bill%20requires%20homeowners'%20associations,application%20on%20a%20mobile%20device.

https://lscarlsonlaw.com/articles/florida-hoa-law-updates-2023-2024-attorney-insights
55   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 1, 7:18pm  

DemoralizerOfPanicans says

A shitload of laws already passed. Addressing everything from conflict of interest/kickbacks to fine limits to mandatory online meeting minutes & mandatory notice of right to pre-fine hearings to restricting the ability of HOAs and NGOs to impose mask requirements. Now more are on the way to further stop KenKarens from pretending they live in an exclusive covenant estate community with properties worth $5M+ apiece and harassing middle class homeowners in modest homes.


More government bandaids?

Okkkaaay
56   DemoralizerOfPanicans   2025 Sep 1, 7:43pm  

MolotovCocktail says


More government bandaids?

Okkkaaay


I have no problem with the government restraining local tyrants and maintaining the right of a homeowner to park in his driveway, put out pink lawn flamingos, have a US flag on a flagpole, and not be fined $200 when he drops a hammer on his foot in his own garage and shouts "Fucking Damnit". Or $200 for sticking an air conditioner in a garage window so he can work on projects in the Florida Summer Heat.

DeSantis is leading a liberation operation against HOAs, many of which were set up by builders to showcase their previous projects to prospective buyers.

Ken Karens who are annoyed by pink lawn flamingos, flapping flags, and seeing a neighbor's garage with an A/C unit in the window... are FREE to work harder and longer to afford more acreage for a more isolated house so they don't have to see all that.
57   Glock-n-Load   2025 Sep 1, 8:00pm  

DemoralizerOfPanicans says

zzyzzx says



https://www.wptv.com/news/state/florida-lawmaker-floats-ban-on-homeowners-associations-amid-growing-backlash

Florida lawmaker floats ban on homeowners associations amid growing backlash


Realtors are fucking terrified right now, which is why this long overdue reform is finally happening. People simply do not want HOAs, but most builds since the 80s are in HOAs.

It was so bad in FL that HOAs were fining deputy sheriffs and NF Rangers for parking their patrol/work vehicles in their own driveways because their vehicles had "decals and branding" on them.

Why would realtors be terrified?
58   WookieMan   2025 Sep 1, 8:44pm  

Glock-n-Load says

Why would realtors be terrified?

A shitty HOA makes it harder to sell a home. Been there done that.
59   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 2, 7:23am  

DemoralizerOfPanicans says


I have no problem with the government restraining local tyrants and maintaining the right of a homeowner to park in his driveway


So you have no problem with the government breaking a contract for you...one that you willingly entered into but you don't want to honor. Got it.

Reminds me of the lack of accountability discussed in this thread: https://patrick.net/post/1381779/2024-07-31-schr-dinger-s-feminism-thread

John: "How much?"
Hooker: "$100 for a sex".
John: "OK, let's do this"
(In the room, he fucks her in the ass)
Hooker: "hey! I never said in the ass!"
John: "Anal sex is sex, look it up"
Hooker: "Bullshit!"
John: "Too bad. Next time you should clarify what it is you are getting yourself into. ESPECIALLY since you engage in magical thinking...like a Housing Expert on PatNet."

Hooker runs outside, finds a cop and screams "this...this..tyrant RAPED ME"

Contracts are the foundation of modern commercial activities. But hey..wtf. don't like it anymore, get the government to break them for you. Why not?

Sane society:

Cop: "Bitch, anal sex is sex, and you agreed to have sex. Now move along before I arrest you."

Our society:

Cop: "You're right! Fuck the contract Down with tryants!"
60   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 2, 7:32am  

WookieMan says

A shitty HOA makes it harder to sell a home. Been there done that.


Sure you have.
61   WookieMan   2025 Sep 2, 10:48am  

MolotovCocktail says

WookieMan says


A shitty HOA makes it harder to sell a home. Been there done that.


Sure you have.

Sold 1,000 at least. How many have you?....
62   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 2, 1:21pm  

WookieMan says

Sold 1,000 at least. How


Bullshit.

Prove it.
63   Tenpoundbass   2025 Sep 2, 1:28pm  

HOAs should be outlawed and the tax burden on those occupants have their taxes accessed accordingly for fees and maintenance.
64   RC2006   2025 Sep 2, 2:07pm  

HOA have there pros and cons. But what I think it comes down to is if you dont want to live in an HOA then dont buy a house in an HOA. Just like if you dont want to live next to a gas station, freeway, or industrial zone. I think HOAs became so popular because of third worlders and the usual problematic types moving into neighborhoods and ruining the place.
65   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 2, 2:40pm  

RC2006 says


But what I think it comes down to is if you dont want to live in an HOA then dont buy a house in an HOA.


Exactly

MolotovCocktail says

I for one don't feel sorry ppl buying into HOAs. Like student loans, nobody put a gun to their heads to sign on the dotted line.

"But...but...everywhere are HOAs if you want to buy a home!" <--- it's like ppl don't fucking read what I wrote or simply cannot accept accountability for their actions. It's still a choice on your part. Everything is a trade off. If you make that choice, you can't bitch about the tyranny of the HOA YOU WILLINGLY SPREAD YOUR BUTTCHEEKS TO. YOU signed on the fucking dotted line.
66   GNL   2025 Sep 2, 3:17pm  

I think HOAs became so big because it helped builders sell homes. I've never looked it up but, it would be interesting to know if HOA homes appreciate faster than non HOA homes. That would be the only thing needed to make everyone want to live/purchase in an HOA. EVERYTHING comes down to $$$.
67   MolotovCocktail   2025 Sep 2, 4:01pm  

GNL says

I think HOAs became so big because it helped builders sell homes. I've never looked it up but, it would be interesting to know if HOA homes appreciate faster than non HOA homes. That would be the only thing needed to make everyone want to live/purchase in an HOA. EVERYTHING comes down to $$$.


A lot of local governments like them...especially the ones that take over maintenance of roads, sewers, water mains and even telecom.
68   Onvacation   2025 Sep 2, 4:25pm  

mell says

Karens are a probmem everywhere

What a great QWERTYan slip!

« First        Comments 30 - 68 of 68        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste