4
0

WH Relents and Allows the FDA To Proceed with Genetically Modified Salmon


               
2012 Dec 21, 4:03am   83,737 views  235 comments

by 121212   follow (0)  

http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2012/12/21/genetically_modified_salmon_white_house_had_blocked_fda_but_now_approval.html

White House Relents and Allows the FDA To Proceed with Genetically Modified Salmon

The Food and Drug Administration today released an electronic version of its environmental assessment for a genetically modified salmon developed by AquaBounty Technologies—effectively giving its preliminary seal of approval on the first transgenic animal to be considered for federal approval.

#environment

Comments 1 - 27 of 235       Last »     Search these comments

1   varmint   2012 Dec 21, 6:21am  

Not a fan of this.

I have no issues with genetic modification, but I don't trust how accurately they can assess the impact of these salmon if they get out into the ocean. Plus salmon farming itself is dumb. Salmon are carnivorous so they have to be fed other fish to grow. Hello? Why not just eat the other fish?

Also, farmed salmon tastes terrible.

2   Peter P   2012 Dec 21, 6:22am  

I don't know what to say...

We are in a brave new world.

3   121212   2012 Dec 21, 7:52am  

I will not eat anymore Salmon unless it's labeled!

I like my GM modified foods labeled!

4   Peter P   2012 Dec 21, 7:52am  

121212 says

I will not eat anymore Salmon

Just find good salmon. You will know when you eat it.

I only eat raw, cured, or poached salmon.

5   121212   2012 Dec 21, 8:07am  

Peter P says

I only eat raw, cured, or poached salmon.

You don't want to eat trademarked Salmon?

or trademarked seeds from Monsanto using roundup?

Why not, a little genetic diversity is fun for all the family.

Food is becoming more and more OWNED. I'm surprised Apple has not gotten in this business yet.

6   Peter P   2012 Dec 21, 8:11am  

Well, choice is a good thing. I am not against genetically modified food. But consumers are free to choose.

7   Peter P   2012 Dec 21, 8:12am  

Yeah, labeling would be good.

8   lostand confused   2012 Dec 21, 8:13am  

Peter P says

Well, choice is a good thing. I am not against genetically modified food. But consumers are free to choose.

Not in this country. They don't label and hence consumers are not free to choose. In Europe they do label and so consumers have a choice.

9   121212   2012 Dec 21, 8:14am  

Peter P says

Well, choice is a good thing. I am not against genetically modified food. But consumers are free to choose.

They don't want us to choose! That's the truth.

They want to force feed it to us.

This proves we are a slave race, always was always will be.

10   Homeboy   2012 Dec 22, 5:00am  

We have been eating genetically modified food for thousands of years. The only difference is, the modifications were done through breeding, and now can be done directly.

I don't recall anyone in the past asking for labels for giant mutant turkeys with gigantic breasts, or tasteless tomatoes bred to have tough outer skins to survive truck rides.

11   lostand confused   2012 Dec 22, 5:06am  

Homeboy says

We have been eating genetically modified food for thousands of years. The only difference is, the modifications were done through breeding, and now can be done directly.

Nah not like this. Today you can put a frog's gene into a tomato or human gene into a cow-so when you drink cow's milk , you are actually drinking very close to human breast milk. That begs the question, if you eat said cow-are you a cannibal??

http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504763_162-20071923-10391704.html

12   Peter P   2012 Dec 22, 6:28am  

I believe our essence is more than our genes.

Genetics do not define humanity. We define humanity individually.

I know if you put a frog's gene into dinosaur DNA it can change sex. I learned that from Jurassic Park. LOL!

13   lostand confused   2012 Dec 22, 7:05am  

Peter P says

Genetics do not define humanity.

So you mind eating babies in the place of veal???

14   New Renter   2012 Dec 22, 7:12am  

lostand confused says

Peter P says

Genetics do not define humanity.

So you mind eating babies in the place of veal???

WTF are you talking about?

15   lostand confused   2012 Dec 22, 7:14am  

New Renter says

lostand confused says



Peter P says



Genetics do not define humanity.


So you mind eating babies in the place of veal???


WTF are you talking about?

Responding to someone who says genes do not define a human.

16   New Renter   2012 Dec 22, 7:17am  

121212 says

Peter P says

Well, choice is a good thing. I am not against genetically modified food. But consumers are free to choose.

They don't want us to choose! That's the truth.

They want to force feed it to us.

This proves we are a slave race, always was always will be.

You can always grow your own food. Discover just how hard it IS to grow enough food to survive on. Enjoy picking moth larvae out of your apples, tripping on ergot, and watching your kids starve when the harvest fails.

You are also free to spend more on organic food, whatever THAT means.

17   121212   2012 Dec 22, 7:20am  

New Renter says

You can always grow your own food. Discover just how hard it IS to grow enough food to survive on

lmfao,it's not that hard...... maybe for you.

I worked my own farm for a while.

18   121212   2012 Dec 22, 7:23am  

New Renter says

You are also free to spend more on organic food, whatever THAT means.

The reason you don't understand the food cycle anymore is because it has been altered.

Once there were 1000's of slaughter houses, now we have "5".

The problems go much deeper and wider, corporations have consolidated the market and changed the process.

What was Organic today was usual practices 40+ years ago.

19   New Renter   2012 Dec 22, 7:48am  

121212 says

New Renter says

You can always grow your own food. Discover just how hard it IS to grow enough food to survive on

lmfao,it's not that hard...... maybe for you.

I worked my own farm for a while.

121212 says

New Renter says

You can always grow your own food. Discover just how hard it IS to grow enough food to survive on

lmfao,it's not that hard...... maybe for you.

I worked my own farm for a while.

True, you got me there - my track record with growing things has been terrible. Why'd you get out of farming?

20   Peter P   2012 Dec 22, 7:54am  

lostand confused says

Peter P says

Genetics do not define humanity.

So you mind eating babies in the place of veal???

Don't you touch my veal! ;-)

Veal Milanese. Yum!

21   New Renter   2012 Dec 22, 8:00am  

121212 says

New Renter says

You are also free to spend more on organic food, whatever THAT means.

The reason you don't understand the food cycle anymore is because it has been altered.

Once there were 1000's of slaughter houses, now we have "5".

The problems go much deeper and wider, corporations have consolidated the market and changed the process.

What was Organic today was usual practices 40+ years ago.

I understand that the term "organic" has too many definitions. Over this past summer I spoke with a couple of farmers. They pointed out as you have that what people today call "organic farming" would better be defined as "traditional farming".

22   Homeboy   2012 Dec 22, 8:13am  

New Renter says

lostand confused says

Peter P says

Genetics do not define humanity.

So you mind eating babies in the place of veal???

WTF are you talking about?

This is why I put lost and confused on ignore.

23   Peter P   2012 Dec 22, 8:15am  

Homeboy says

New Renter says

lostand confused says

Peter P says

Genetics do not define humanity.

So you mind eating babies in the place of veal???

WTF are you talking about?

This is why I put lost and confused on ignore.

It was obviously a joke.

I only ignore people who ignore me. Seems fair.

24   New Renter   2012 Dec 22, 8:25am  

Peter P says

Homeboy says

New Renter says

lostand confused says

Peter P says

Genetics do not define humanity.

So you mind eating babies in the place of veal???

WTF are you talking about?

This is why I put lost and confused on ignore.

It was obviously a joke.

I only ignore people who ignore me. Seems fair.

If so LaC has a strange sense of humor.

25   Peter P   2012 Dec 22, 8:28am  

New Renter says

If so LaC has a strange sense of humor.

Or perhaps strange IS a sense of humor? :-)

26   lostand confused   2012 Dec 22, 9:13am  

Peter P says

lostand confused says



Peter P says



Genetics do not define humanity.


So you mind eating babies in the place of veal???


Don't you touch my veal! ;-)


Veal Milanese. Yum!

LOL!! I love me veal and every sort of meat! But I just prefer labelling in the case of Genetically modified food. I think the customer should be given the right to choose-it is our money. If Europe can achieve that, it is much easier here. But Monsanto and their ilk and their lobbying efforts prevent that. You can't put the genie back in the bottle-genetic modified food is here to stay. But there is nothing wrong with labelling.

Now philosophically-yes. We are all one, start off as a single cell, then grow and consume things of the earth , excrete stuff back into the earth and finally our body is absorbed back into the earth . I am not an atheist, defnitely believe something is there, beyond science and DNA-but file that in the unkown category. Some of the older religions all call that the unkowable, the great unkown and do not try and define that which is beyond our puny human defnition. So to me science is science -which is ever evolving as our understanding of the world evolves and expands and philosphy/essence/divine is something else. Why try and mix that with science and make it dull, boring and repetitive?

27   121212   2012 Dec 26, 4:10am  

New Renter says

121212 says

New Renter says

You are also free to spend more on organic food, whatever THAT means.

The reason you don't understand the food cycle anymore is because it has been altered.

Once there were 1000's of slaughter houses, now we have "5".

The problems go much deeper and wider, corporations have consolidated the market and changed the process.

What was Organic today was usual practices 40+ years ago.

I understand that the term "organic" has too many definitions. Over this past summer I spoke with a couple of farmers. They pointed out as you have that what people today call "organic farming" would better be defined as "traditional farming".

Organic farming = Traditional Farming

We are being screwed! From Monsanto downwards.

Comments 1 - 27 of 235       Last »     Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste