patrick.net

Many participants in here, myself included, are in the "wait for the free market to return" camp. The government subsidies for housing via GSE loans, the MID, prop 13, RE agent-favoring MLS system, shadow inventory, squatters and low interest rates are all items on a (probably incomplete) list of things that us would-be buyers wish to see go away in hopes of lowering house prices. When/If some of these items go away, lots of of us probably figure that it would be OK to buy, and many of us post about how adamant we are about not buying into our current rigged-system.

OK. Obviously, we all have a pretty strong interest in buying houses, or else we wouldn't be spending time in here worrying about it. Buying a house is, for strong personal reasons, a really big aspiration for most people.

So, what if none of the things in the list above change in the next 10+ years? It isn't totally out of the realm of possibility. As far as I can tell, the groups that want to keep the game rigged like it is are also the groups that have the ability to change the rules of the game. The rest of us that are chasing some version of the American Dream can all pine away and wish for a fair, rational system, but we really do lack the means to get those with vested interests in rigging the game to un-rig it. Don't get me wrong, I have a really hard time seeing the system as it operates now lasting. Despite this, short- to mid-term economic behavior seems to be perfectly capable of doing totally irrational things. As far as I am concerned, 10 years is at the start of a "mid-term" time span when planning economic moves. Long-term, in my mind, is 30+ years, or about enough time for one generation to produce the next.

So, say that 10 years from now the game is still rigged and we all know it and hate it. How many of you would have saved & over-paid somewhere in that span? We are all waiting around for a train that we think is coming, but we aren't really sure of when. What if it doesn't come for a REALLY long time? For all of the frustration we seem to have, how many of us are really going to let it stop us? Will you eventually give-in?

Chances are that I would end up over-paying after a few more years of saving (and put down 30-50%). Despite the fact that I despise all of the crookedness in the system and live below my means, I want some personal space to run a workshop that I can walk to in 5 seconds, and to have a yard with big trees to do stupid stuff in with my climbing gear. God help me when I decide to have kids, but it would be nice to have a yard for them to run around in and provide me with manual labor when they are old enough (I knew how to use a jackhammer by the time I was 12, and spent a lot of weekends digging sprinkler line trenches and putting up drywall...it builds character, or something). The main reason I want to avoid overpaying, aside from the obvious short/mid-term issues, is the long term issue of being stuck with high property tax bills. My fiancee and I are fine with buying a $500k SFH, and in a couple more years we can put 40-50% down. We could put 25% down now, but we are, "waiting for that train." Anything over $500k is too much of a financial liability as far as we are concerned.

So, despite all of my idealism about not participating in a rigged system, I am pretty sure I'd cave in and participate at some point. I bet lots of us will. I am fairly certain that those that run this rigged system know this, and that gives them even more incentive to keep it rigged. "Look at these stupid peons...they piss & moan now, but give them a few years and they let us shoot a load in their face anyway!"

#housing