0
0

Hawaii Big Island hotel recommendations?


               
2026 Feb 4, 4:00pm   1,044 views  9 comments

by Patrick   follow (56)  

Wife and I are going to the Big Island for four nights. Flying into Kona, so thinking two nights there and two nights in Hilo.

Prices are all over the map, even for same hotel, same dates. Might be $120 on a link off of https://www.tripadvisor.com/ for The Inn at Kulaniapia Falls, but then if you look direct on their site, https://www.waterfall.net/book-your-stay they are all more than $400. Smells like bullshit.

Reviews are also wildly variable for the same place. Might have a ton of 5 star reviews, but also a couple dozen 1 star pointing out hair in sink, mold, etc etc.

Any of you guys have good hotel experiences on the Big Island?

Comments 1 - 9 of 9        Search these comments

1   Al_Sharpton_for_President   @   2026 Feb 4, 7:31pm  

We stayed at the Fairmont Orchid in Puako. Got a killer deal through Costco. Our basic room had a plumbing issue so we were upgraded to a garden/partial ocean view. Incredibly beautiful grounds. Good beach access.

I ate Mahi almost every night but I highly recommend this Italian restaurant. The short rib pizza with mascarpone os amazing.

https://pueososteria.com/
2   Al_Sharpton_for_President   @   2026 Feb 5, 5:47am  

I dig Hilo but the wife doesn’t. Liliʻuokalani Gardens is really nice.

If you drive around the outskirts of town, you can find chill communities with waterfalls, streams, in total nature. I took Hawaii Belt Rd. north to Old Mamalahoa Hwy to Onomea Bay Trail and the Hawai‘i Tropical Botanical Garden. Really nice area, waterfalls, streams, lush. Now that would be a chill place to live.

Hilo does have a significant homeless population. The big pagoda-type building in the middle of town is a crash pad for all sorts.
3   FuckTheMainstreamMedia   @   2026 Feb 5, 11:23am  

Airbnb a better option? I don’t know how available because the state there passed some laws restricting vacation rentals.

If you can do more days you may want to consider that. My favorite thing on vacations like these is to get out and explore and the Big Island is built for that. Wife’s favorite thing was shopping in Kona (but of course).

I enjoyed seeing so much we drove around the upper half of the island. Gorgeous black sand beach just north of Kona and then along the coast. Tropical jungle on the norther tip of the island with a few charming towns. Crazy how humid it was there.

Then came down the mountain…seriously ranches and pine trees…to Waimea and then headed over to the eastern coast on 19 and then 240 north to an overlook of a valley that was featured in Jurassic park. I wish we had the time to hike down into the vally(restricted access) .

Then on the coast towards Hilo. Stopped at Akaka Falls state park. Easy pathway to overlooking the falls. My parents were both about 72 or 73 at the time and had no problems with it. I think it was like a half mile loop and was paved.

I regret not spending a day at the volcanos and driving around the southern part of the island.
4   Patrick   @   2026 Feb 5, 11:35am  

FuckTheMainstreamMedia says


Airbnb a better option?


I booked two VRBO's, two nights each. Hopefully that will work out well.

Airbnb was insufferably woke for the longest time, and I still haven't forgiven them for their years of overt anti-white hatred, so I went with VRBO instead.

VRBO was slightly disappointing in the booking process. One promising place listed "all fees included" and then when you start to book, imposes a $59 insurance fee. I tried to point out the dishonesty on their help page, but just got AI which told me that a mandatory fee for insurance is not a fee.

Then I called and got a woman who could not really speak English. When I explained that the hostess was lying about "all fees included" she just went silent. Last try: got some Indian guy on the phone, also hard to understand. He gave me the same bullshit line that a fee for insurance is somehow not a fee. Ugh.

Still, I have reasonably high hopes for these two rental places. I'll post how it turns out.
5   SharkyP   @   2026 Feb 5, 11:42am  

Did you do the steaks at the ranch?
6   mell   @   2026 Feb 5, 4:48pm  

Stayed in a fabulous vacation rental in the big island for 10 days many moons ago. Right next to the Ocean and tide pools. As much as they suck these days, esp. for longer stays they may be the better option.
7   FortWayneHatesRealtors   @   2026 Feb 5, 5:54pm  

Billie Eyelash will think you are going to vacation on stolen land.
8   Patrick   @   2026 Feb 5, 7:41pm  

mell says


Stayed in a fabulous vacation rental in the big island for 10 days many moons ago. Right next to the Ocean and tide pools.


Yes, we rented an incredible cottage for cheap a few blocks from Poipu Beach on Kauai maybe 20 years ago. Not even sure how we found it, because Airbnb didn't exist at the time.

I looked in my records. It was 22 years ago, and from https://www.kauaivacationrentals.com/
9   mell   @   2026 Feb 5, 7:58pm  

Patrick says


mell says


Stayed in a fabulous vacation rental in the big island for 10 days many moons ago. Right next to the Ocean and tide pools.


Yes, we rented an incredible cottage for cheap a few blocks from Poipu Beach on Kauai maybe 20 years ago. Not even sure how we found it, because Airbnb didn't exist at the time.

I looked in my records. It was 22 years ago, and from https://www.kauaivacationrentals.com/


Yeah and we found a guy who was a lava diver of generations and got us with his boat within 20 ft of the active Volcanoes with the lava flowing into the ocean and you had to brush any ashes falling on your skin off immediately. I think it was all Craigslist.

Much less regulated and monopolized back then, hence much better quality of what you were looking for, despite being a gamble. We left before sunrise and when we got back into that little deserted shore/bay we departed from, the surf was so high that it threw my gf back then through the boat so she had to get stitched. He had yelled to hold on really tight well before so can't really fault him.

Read that he was charged a couple years later with some bs after a couple from OR, likely leftoids, sued him for some "dangerous experience". It was a truly amazing trip.

https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/02/26/lava-tour-company-operator-face-another-lawsuit-over-lava-bomb-incident/

https://www.naturepl.com/stock-photo-videographer-shane-turpin-films-pillow-lava-erupting-underwater-at-image01170238.html?srsltid=AfmBOoq4gH_qsUqkYAxgm48LAnV59qTv0ZFqc50uA1RNAMqpIEvgpm0X

Comments 1 - 9 of 9        Search these comments

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   users   suggestions   gaiste