4
0

Why are markets soaring as the economy tanks?


 invite response                
2021 Feb 27, 5:44pm   720 views  38 comments

by Patrick   ➕follow (55)   💰tip   ignore  

https://spectator.us/topic/up-crash-markets-soaring-economy-tanks/

Shops are boarded up. More than four million Britons are on furlough with little idea of whether they will have jobs to go back to. Global trade has hit levels last seen a decade ago, and government deficits are soaring, while most developed economies have seen output shrink by 10 percent, a collapse not seen since the Great Depression of the 1930s. On just about every measure imaginable, the global economy has never been in worse shape, and we are all a lot poorer.

And yet here is a puzzle. Why can’t we see any evidence for that in the financial markets? Instead we are witnessing a series of extraordinary, epic bull markets. ...

And yet the Up Crash is also completely explicable, even if not entirely rational. Powerful trends are coming together. The global policy elite has formed a consensus on a version of free-spending Keynesianism that has not been seen since the 1960s. Technology has been accelerated by the pandemic, disrupting old industries, and creating new ways of working at lightning speed. ...

The most immediate cause is the fact we are experiencing a stimulus on an epic global scale. Central bankers, finance ministers, academics, think tanks and the International Monetary Fund and World Bank have formed an ultra-Keynesianism consensus. We have not been in this territory since the 1960s, with wild spending on moonshots, the Vietnam War and lavish social programs. President Joe Biden has promised a $1.9 trillion blast to lift the American economy out of recession and create a green revolution. His plan includes sending a $1,400 check to everyone earning less than $100,000 a year: in effect, free money. ...

We are surfing a tidal wave of easy money. Total global debt, according to the Bank for International Settlements, rose by $24 trillion last year to an all-time high of $281 trillion. Between them, governments, companies and householders owe 360 percent of GDP now, compared with less than 200 percent a decade ago.

Is anyone worried about that? Not really. A few economists have rung alarm bells: Larry Summers, Bill Clinton’s Treasury secretary and a former president of Harvard, has fretted publicly that Biden’s plan is too big, but such concerns are quickly drowned out. ...

Where will it all end? We have seen Up Crashes before. An epic bull market started in 1932 even as the Great Depression ground on and the world headed unstoppably towards a global war. The Long Depression, the slump that lasted for the last three decades of the 19th century, also witnessed railway and emerging markets booms. Easy money, technological change and rapid shifts in economic power between continents are a potent, combustible mixture. And yet the Up Crash of the 1930s ended in war, and the consensual ultra-Keynesianism of the 1960s ended in the stagflation and chaos of the 1970s. Once the pandemic is over, we are meant to be heading for a new ‘Roaring Twenties’ as economies flare back to life: a re-run of The Great Gatsby era, but with less jazz and more Teslas. It is not impossible. But history suggests that a chaotic or catastrophic ending to the boom is more likely.

Comments 1 - 38 of 38        Search these comments

1   Rin   2021 Feb 27, 6:23pm  

Patrick says
Once the pandemic is over, we are meant to be heading for a new ‘Roaring Twenties’ as economies flare back to life: a re-run of The Great Gatsby era, but with less jazz and more Teslas. It is not impossible. But history suggests that a chaotic or catastrophic ending to the boom is more likely.


https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-01-26/roaring-twenties-2020s-will-try-to-roar-like-1920s-after-covid

Someone wrote a bloomberg article comparing the 1920s with the 2020s.

I'd say that the biggest difference is that today, we're a highly finance oriented society.

In other words, with all the new tech of the 1900s: the automobile, the telephone, the washing machine, etc, there were jobs which went with them. So in effect, where women had no meaningful well paying work earlier, during the 1920s, there were practically limitless jobs for switch board operators.

In contrast with today, there are numerous applicants for limited jobs in IT or finance, with only health care adding headcount (and even that's shaky w/ budget cuts & reduced services). Many other jobs are a part of the gig economy, volatile and unstable.

And also, it's really the addition of the endless unemployment extensions with added benefits, which is keeping things afloat. So while there's pent up demand, if those unemployment checks stop, the music is over and all that demand would disappear with ppl lining up at the food banks looking for their next meal.
2   Onvacation   2021 Feb 27, 6:51pm  

Just went by Fry's Electronics

"After nearly 36 years in business as the one-stop-shop and online resource for high-tech professionals across nine states and 31 stores, Fry’s Electronics, Inc. (“Fry’s” or “Company”), has made the difficult decision to shut down its operations and close its business permanently as a result of changes in the retail industry and the challenges posed by the Covid-19 pandemic."
3   mell   2021 Feb 27, 6:52pm  

We went up on all the anticipated stimulus and tech craze from !Covid!, now there's nothing more to anticipate and the market will either go sideways or somewhat tank in an oscillating manner which may already have started. Inflation is preventing a crash but the bull run is over, select stocks only.
4   RC2006   2021 Feb 27, 7:31pm  

Onvacation says
Just went by Fry's Electronics

"After nearly 36 years in business as the one-stop-shop and online resource for high-tech professionals across nine states and 31 stores, Fry’s Electronics, Inc. (“Fry’s” or “Company”), has made the difficult decision to shut down its operations and close its business permanently as a result of changes in the retail industry and the challenges posed by the Covid-19 pandemic."


Another victim of Amazon.
5   Patrick   2021 Feb 27, 7:31pm  

A simple admission of obvious truths would change the whole world for the better:

- outdoor masks are frankly stupid, because there has been not one documented case of casual outdoor transmission anywhere on earth
- indoor masks are pretty stupid as well, because they simply don't work at all
- the virus is mostly harmless. the only people at real risk are the elderly. the average US age of a wuhan virus death is greater than the US life expectancy

We should just ignore the whole damn thing except for keeping the elderly isolated, and the whole problem just goes away.

But the tech billionaires and new vaccine billionaires don't like that idea one bit.
6   clambo   2021 Feb 27, 7:47pm  

The reason the stock market has not cratered is interest rates are low.

People who have cash to invest are usually choosing between bonds or stocks; today stocks are more attractive than they were when interest rates were high.

Another reason has been mentioned; the consumer is not broke because the government keeps paying people not to work and to have children. So, corporate profits are continuing.

What can ruin it is Biden and his ilk raising taxes and the cost of energy.

I’m nervous about it because I’m greedy and I want another $500,000 of net worth before 2022.
7   Rin   2021 Feb 27, 7:53pm  

clambo says
I’m nervous about it because I’m greedy and I want another $500,000 of net worth before 2022.


I simply don't want looters showing up at my house. Realize, I have a RealDoll at home so I'm perfectly satisfied not interacting with the rest of humanity anymore.
8   Patrick   2021 Feb 27, 8:12pm  

clambo says
People who have cash to invest are usually choosing between bonds or stocks; today stocks are more attractive than they were when interest rates were high.


I just read one explanation for last week's market falls is that the 10 year bond yield went above the S&P dividend yield, both somewhere around 1.5%. So you can get more actual cash out of bonds than out of stocks now (on average) with zero risk of default for government bonds.

Of course you also have very little risk of getting rich with bonds, too. And quite a bit of risk of losing to inflation.
9   Patrick   2021 Feb 27, 8:13pm  

clambo says
I’m nervous about it because I’m greedy and I want another $500,000 of net worth before 2022.



@clambo But say you get that extra $500K of net worth this year. What do you do with it then? Let it ride?
10   komputodo   2021 Feb 27, 8:15pm  

Patrick says
We should just ignore the whole damn thing except for keeping the elderly isolated, and the whole problem just goes away.

Do the elderly need us to keep them isolated or can they decide for themselves?
11   Patrick   2021 Feb 27, 9:46pm  

Good point. They should certainly be able to decide for themselves.

But not able to decide that we must all stay home, or wear masks, or other ridiculous intrusions on our freedoms.
12   clambo   2021 Feb 28, 5:55am  

Re: what I would do with another $500k :

I will be more aggressive with my travel and spending. I might take the Baja Plunge with $100-$150k, get a shack or etc. down there.

I’m still inclined to “let it ride”=stay invested in stocks (I’m about 10% bonds in funds).

I’m also worried about our absurd government money wasting and debt, it might be a good time to get into Swiss stocks because of the value of the US dollar falling and Swiss companies are generally good.
I know of two Swiss funds, one at Franklin Templeton and one at iShares.

I rolled the dice with a few stocks and made a bundle; it’s really fun. I’m a believer in mutual funds because they are generally a better idea but I want to feed my greed and I need more kicks.
13   theoakman   2021 Feb 28, 6:25am  

Bonds are a waste of time and will wreck a lot of people. 1% yield while the fed inflates M1 at 20% a year. A lot of tech stocks left conventional value stocks in the dust. But at the end of the day, at some point, it's still going to be about how much money they make and how much money they yield. The amazon model can't work for everyone. Stocks like Exxon Mobile, BP, Altria, Verizon and so forth are still yielding upwards of 5 to 7% and they haven't had a run up. Moreover, the whole idea of indexing and forget about worked well for everyone in America, however, if you've done that around the world, they've gone almost nowhere. Foreign stocks have completely decoupled from the US. When you look at US stocks vs the world, we are in major bubble territory. So the foreign stocks offer you a chance to obtain an uncorrelated asset that is at an all time low relative to US stocks.

The fed is out of bullets and they have no ability to reign in the punch bowl. Free money for everyone and a national debt that can skyrocket with just an uptick of interest rates. My portfolio is very defensive and prepared for market carnage.

20% Dividend Blue Chips
20% Foreign stock ETFs that yield dividends (EWS, EWT, EWL) from Singapore, Switzerland, Taiwan.
40% Precious Metals, 80% Silver, 20% Gold
1% Bitcoin, which I'm slowly acquiring up to 5%

The rest I'm in is cash which I will deploy as I expect all assets to fall during some sort of mass liquidation, just like in 2008.
14   clambo   2021 Feb 28, 6:41am  

What is odd is when I look at my Vanguard account on the iPad app it shows some bond fund capital gains (inherited in 2017).

A good fund for the cautious is Wellington and for the more income oriented Wellesley Income.
But, I like everything actually, I’m a hoarder.

I’m not a fan of metals or cash; my friend bought thousands of dollars worth of silver about the same time I added to my Apple shares; he is about 40% underwater (won’t admit it) today. I can buy a house with my AAPL capital gains, but I don’t rub it in. He’s glad uncle Sam doesn’t know what is in his safe, my shit is all known to the government (except the variable annuity, those are secret) 🤐
15   HeadSet   2021 Feb 28, 7:36am  

clambo says
I rolled the dice with a few stocks and made a bundle;

Must be nice. I am mildly ahead in stocks, but would have been way ahead if I did not buy SunEdison and JCPenney.

How would your stocks be doing without your AAPL bonanza?
16   clambo   2021 Feb 28, 10:06am  

I’m lucky, I have bought some good stocks and not lost money.
The mutual funds are good, but I have had them for years.
My stock picks are few; Apple, Alibaba, Deere, Roku.
I have 15 shares of GME just for the hell of it.
Around 1999 I bought Sun, Compaq, Apple, I got annoyed with eTrade, Sun went down, Compaq fired my friend to hire guys from India so I sold everything (big mistake selling any Apple).
I believe mutual funds are the essence of investing but it is fun trying to choose a stock.
17   Patrick   2021 Feb 28, 10:10am  

I avoid mutual funds because they almost all have fees which are a significant drag on their income, not to mention pointless churn.

There was a Fidelity study which showed that a lot of the best investors are actually dead:


Best Investors Are Dead: Fidelity Study
NOVEMBER 27, 2019 ALEX SMITH INVESTING
Fidelity noted an internal performance review on accounts to determine which type of investors received the best returns between 2003 and 2013. The customer account audit revealed that the best investors are dead or inactive.

The inactive investors were people who switched jobs and “forgot” about an old 401(k).


https://wealthydiligence.com/best-investors-are-dead/

The lesson seems to be to do nothing.
18   clambo   2021 Feb 28, 2:58pm  

There are mutual funds which have essentially no fee; Vanguard Index Admiral shares.
I think those have 0.05% fee.
Fidelity has "zero" funds , one is their Total Stock Market Index fund.
This has 0% management fee.
I have a few bucks in it.
Index funds are tax efficient too.
19   indigenous   2021 Feb 28, 3:14pm  

This is the answer to your conundrum

Look at the top row and compare it to the bottom row

20   Ceffer   2021 Feb 28, 3:20pm  

I have pretty much been a 'dead' investor. Even Vanguard pesters me to use their commission based personal advisors. I'm too lazy to even communicate with such a person, much less become entangled with them in my portfolio balances.

The history of the investments suggest that this was OK, they have reliably gone up in excess of market averages.

However, It is very clear that there is an inbred superstitious necessity for a sense of control and desire to exceed probability in order to congratulate oneself that one is special.

I also think that men are biologically programmed in an "all or nothing" mindset that promotes gambling and grandiosity, primarily in order to afford access to women and reproduction.

My own advice would be to try to sublimate these gambling tendencies in ways that are not destructive to the gradual growth of value. Find ways to gamble that don't fuck up your shit.
21   Patrick   2021 Feb 28, 6:40pm  

Ceffer says
I also think that men are biologically programmed in an "all or nothing" mindset that promotes gambling and grandiosity, primarily in order to afford access to women and reproduction.


I agree with this, and think it follows directly from the ability of men to have far more children than women.

When men win, they can win very bigly. Some sultan in Morocco had 800 children, iirc.

The Spaniards in the New World pretty much replaced the entire native male line with their own.

There are many such examples. I think it follows that risk-taking men were sufficiently rewarded for those risks on average that genes for taking risk propagated among men.
22   NuttBoxer   2021 Mar 1, 12:27pm  

It's the appearance of profitability, with none of benefits. Same thing happened in Weimer Germany right before the collapse.
23   Automan Empire   2021 Mar 1, 12:37pm  

I'm old enough to remember when it was called the Dow Jones INDUSTRIAL average. It represented actual wealth generation, largely from raw resources.

For a long time the DOW has represented mostly the tertiary service economy, meaning high DOW average means high sales of imported goods enriching the few and moved/peddled by peon class people. Hearing people cite the DOW as their proof that the economy is booming has been frustrating for 20+ years now.
24   Hircus   2021 Mar 2, 8:11am  

Onvacation says
Just went by Fry's Electronics

"After nearly 36 years in business as the one-stop-shop and online resource for high-tech professionals across nine states and 31 stores, Fry’s Electronics, Inc. (“Fry’s” or “Company”), has made the difficult decision to shut down its operations and close its business permanently as a result of changes in the retail industry and the challenges posed by the Covid-19 pandemic."


the Bezos laugh

25   NuttBoxer   2021 Mar 2, 10:45am  

The Fry's in Phoenix by our house was always super empty despite occupying a huge space. Was always kind of surreal shopping there..
26   WookieMan   2021 Mar 2, 11:26am  

NuttBoxer says
The Fry's in Phoenix by our house was always super empty despite occupying a huge space. Was always kind of surreal shopping there..

I was just out there in Anthem last week. Drove by a Fry's. Not sure exactly where as we did 4 courses, well 3 were in civilization. I think along Cave Creek highway? Might have been Anthem? Was drinking and golfing (not driving myself). Either way, empty parking lot.
27   Hircus   2021 Mar 2, 3:25pm  

NuttBoxer says
The Fry's in Phoenix by our house was always super empty despite occupying a huge space. Was always kind of surreal shopping there..


Too bad. I always liked Frys and shopped there for many years.

I recently discovered they also had a Fry's grocery store in AZ, which was actually pretty nice.
28   Onvacation   2021 Mar 2, 4:04pm  

Hircus says

Too bad. I always liked Frys and shopped there for many years.

They always had stuff. Lots of stuff. They used to have geeks in all of the departments that could find the capacitor you needed for your filter circuit. Last time I was in there (Concord Fry's) the employees couldn't even tell you where to find USB cords.

Geeks still build things, but they went to the internet for supplies years ago. Fry's was just a place to buy some headphones, a cheap computer, or a USB cord when you didn't want to wait for it to get delivered.
29   EBGuy   2021 Mar 2, 4:12pm  

As California's Rich Get Richer, State Expects $10.5 Billion Surplus Despite Slow Economy
At the end of 2020, California had lost a record 1.6 million jobs during the pandemic. Nearly a half-million people stopped even trying to look for work. Business properties saw their value plummet more than 30%.
But California’s bank account is overflowing. As of January, the state’s tax collections were $10.5 billion ahead of projections. By the end of the fiscal year on July 1, Gov. Gavin Newsom and the state Legislature could have a $19 billion surplus to spend.
It’s so much money that, for just the second time ever, the state is projected to trigger a state law requiring the government to send refunds to taxpayers.
30   Hircus   2021 Mar 2, 4:18pm  

Onvacation says
Last time I was in there (Concord Fry's) the employees couldn't even tell you where to find USB cords.


Ya they got pretty bad towards the end.
31   RWSGFY   2021 Mar 2, 4:19pm  

EBGuy says
It’s so much money that, for just the second time ever, the state is projected to trigger a state law requiring the government to send refunds to taxpayers.


They'll find a way around it.
32   Onvacation   2021 Mar 2, 4:26pm  

EBGuy says
It’s so much money that, for just the second time ever, the state is projected to trigger a state law requiring the government to send refunds to taxpayers.

FUCK! Why did you have to tell them?

Now they are going to spend it before they have to give it back
33   EBGuy   2021 Mar 2, 5:30pm  

Around $4 billion of the total [$1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan Act] will go in emergency relief to California’s transit agencies.
I imagine some of the surplus will got to fill giant holes like that....
34   Automan Empire   2021 Mar 2, 6:03pm  

NuttBoxer says
The Fry's ... was always super empty despite occupying a huge space


Mega square footage retail buildings are becoming somewhat of a liability in the age of the internet. I tried Fry's a few times long LONG ago and quit going because it felt like a giant Big Lots or Wal-Mart of electronics and the shopping experience was never pleasant.

I wonder how the Simon Group is doing. They're one of the biggest mall owner/operators in the country. A year ago, they bought one of their biggest tenants, Forever 21, out in bankruptcy. The deal closed during the opening stages of the whole Coronavirus thing, imagine the buyer's remorse now.
35   WookieMan   2021 Mar 3, 4:38am  

Automan Empire says
I wonder how the Simon Group is doing.

Financially I'm not certain. I can tell you the two I know are Simon properties around me are packed when I drive that way. Just wear a mask and stand on your floor dot. Throw up a bunch of hand sani stations and poof, covid is gone.

Outlet malls will be pretty popular with the Karen's after this. Usually they're open air until you get into the store. They own quite a few of those across the country. Big huge indoor malls are a dying breed. Figure out how to repurpose them and you'd be rich. Usually though the property taxes will kill you with structures that size and they're better to tear down and repurpose the land.
36   NuttBoxer   2021 Mar 3, 10:33am  

WookieMan says
I was just out there in Anthem last week. Drove by a Fry's. Not sure exactly where as we did 4 courses, well 3 were in civilization. I think along Cave Creek highway? Might have been Anthem? Was drinking and golfing (not driving myself). Either way, empty parking lot.


This was the one on Greenway right by the 17 freeway. Had those Asian looking statues out front you see in Mr Robot
37   NuttBoxer   2021 Mar 3, 10:34am  

Hircus says
I recently discovered they also had a Fry's grocery store in AZ, which was actually pretty nice.


Yep, they're everywhere, the same company as Ralph's in California.
38   NuttBoxer   2021 Mar 3, 10:38am  

Automan Empire says
A year ago, they bought one of their biggest tenants, Forever 21, out in bankruptcy. The deal closed during the opening stages of the whole Coronavirus thing, imagine the buyer's remorse now.


All bailouts are for the purpose of saving the stock-holders(i.e. the banks).

Please register to comment:

api   best comments   contact   latest images   memes   one year ago   random   suggestions